Liquidation: Shares Can Be Extinguished Without Compensation After Going-Concern Sale: NCLT Hyderabad
The Hyderabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), on 20 November, held that a company sold as a going concern during liquidation can extinguish its existing share capital without compensation to give effect to the acquisition and enable the successful bidder to manage the company.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Rajeev Bhardwaj and Technical Member Sanjay Puri partly allowed an application filed by Byndla Srinivas, the successful bidder of ICSA (India) Ltd, seeking extinguishment of the existing share capital and restructuring of the company's capital following its sale as a going concern during liquidation. It observed:
“...Considering that the Corporate Debtor was sold as a going concern in liquidation and the liquidation proceedings were subsequently closed under Regulation 45(3)(a) of the IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016, extinguishment of the existing share capital is necessary to give effect to the acquisition and facilitate the administration of the Corporate Debtor by the Successful Bidder.
Accordingly, the existing equity shares, including those held by the erstwhile promoters and public shareholders, shall stand extinguished without consideration, along with the rights and liabilities attached thereto.”
Following the acquisition, Srinivas approached the Tribunal seeking changes to the company's existing share capital and shareholding structure to implement the acquisition.
He sought cancellation of the existing demat holdings, issuance of a new ISIN, restoration of trading and listing, restructuring of the shareholding pattern, and waiver of outstanding listing fees, penalties and other regulatory compliances.
The Stock Exchanges opposed the reliefs, arguing that the sale covered only the company's name and goodwill and did not involve the sale of its business and assets as a going concern.
They also pointed out that the company's shares remained suspended from trading and that the applicant had to approach the Exchanges and comply with the applicable regulatory framework.
The Tribunal held that extinguishing the existing share capital was necessary to give effect to the going-concern acquisition. It clarified that the existing equity shares, including those held by erstwhile promoters and public shareholders, would stand extinguished without consideration.
However, it declined to grant the other reliefs concerning cancellation of demat holdings, issuance of a fresh ISIN, recognition of the restructured shareholding pattern, approval of fresh allotments and waiver of listing fees and penalties. It observed that these matters fell within the securities law framework administered by the competent statutory and regulatory authorities.
Further, the Bench noted that Srinivas had not approached the Stock Exchanges seeking revocation of the trading suspension. He had also not submitted the requisite corporate action request to the depository.
Accordingly, the NCLT partly allowed the application and granted liberty to the applicant to approach the concerned authorities for the remaining reliefs.
For Applicant: Mr. Srikanth Rathi, Ld. Counsel
For Respondent No. 1: Ms. Devina Bhandari, Ld. Counsel
For Respondent No. 2: Ms. Soujanya Ramaswamy, Ld. Counsel
For Respondent No. 3: Ms. Vidhi Sharma, Ld. Counsel