The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Bengaluru, on 23 October held that a statutory charge created by operation of law does not constitute a security interest under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), and therefore cannot make the State tax department a secured creditor.

A Bench comprising Judicial Member Sunil Kumar Aggarwal and Technical Member Radhakrishna Sreepada held that the Explanation inserted in Section 3(31) of the IBC by the IBC (Amendment) Act, 2026, applies retrospectively and restricts the applicability of the Supreme Court's ruling in State Tax Officer v. Rainbow Papers Ltd. It observed:

“The legislative amendment although subsequent to the filing of application under disposal yet having been held to operate retrospectively, has unambiguously altered the canvassed preposition by excluding from the ambit of Security Interest a charge created merely by operation of law.

As a corollary, the Applicant cannot claim to be a Secured-Creditor and seek classification as such by the respondent on the basis of statutory first charge under Section 48 of the GVAT Act.”

On 3 December 2020, the Tribunal ordered the liquidation of Camson Bio Technologies Limited, and the liquidator invited claims by 2 January 2021. The State Tax Officer, Ahmedabad, claimed that it learnt about the liquidation only in early 2022, when it attached the company's bank account.

The department filed a claim of Rs. 1,62,97,700 towards Gujarat Value Added Tax (GVAT) and Central Sales Tax (CST) dues on 25 February 2022, 418 days after the deadline. After the liquidator rejected the claim, the department approached the Tribunal under Section 42 of the IBC.

Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Rainbow Papers, the department argued that the statutory first charge under Section 48 of the Gujarat Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (GVAT Act), created a security interest under Section 3(31) of the IBC.

It also pointed out that the Supreme Court had dismissed the review petitions against the ruling in Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State Tax Officer. Further, it argued that Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. Raman Ispat Pvt. Ltd. had neither overruled nor diluted Rainbow Papers.

The liquidator opposed the application, arguing that a charge created by operation of law does not constitute a consensual security interest. It submitted that Section 53(1)(e) of the IBC places government dues in the relevant distribution category and that the Form-B public announcement had adequately notified the department of the liquidation.

The Tribunal noted that the Explanation inserted in Section 3(31) clarifies that a security interest must arise from an agreement or arrangement involving the act of two or more parties. A charge created merely by operation of law does not meet this requirement.

Further, the Bench relied on the Madras High Court's ruling in Avenue Realty v. Assistant Commissioner, Srirangam (GST Circle), which treated the amendment as clarificatory and retrospective. It also relied on the NCLAT's decisions in Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority v. Anand Sonbhadra and State Tax Officer v. CA Vinod T. Agrawal.

Accordingly, the NCLT dismissed the application.

For the Applicant: Advocate Hitesh P. Vachhani

For the Respondent: Advocate Vikram C.

Tags:    
Case Title :  State Tax Officer (1), Unit-4, Ahmedabad v. Liquidator of Camson Bio Technologies LimitedCase Number :  I.A. No. 723/2024 in C.P. (IB) No. 52/BB/2017