The Ahmedabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) on 17 November held that the sale of a corporate debtor as a going concern during liquidation cannot be equated with its revival under an approved resolution plan.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Chitra Hankare and Technical Member Dr VG Venkata Chalapathy rejected an application filed by Rajendra Dallaram Choudhary, the successful purchaser of ORG Informatics Ltd, seeking various reliefs, concessions and exemptions following its acquisition during liquidation. It observed:
“....this CD has been liquidated over 6 years before this application was filed and there is no benefit or value arrived at in favour of creditors on such sale and cannot be equated to a revival under resolution plan.”
Choudhary filed the application under Section 60(5) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), after acquiring ORG Informatics Ltd as a going concern during liquidation proceedings.
The corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) against the company commenced following an application filed by TVS Interconnect Systems Pvt. Ltd. under Section 9 of the IBC. The NCLT admitted the application on 27 November 2018 and ordered the company's liquidation on 20 November 2019, appointing Kiran Shah as liquidator.
Initially, Choudhary participated in a sale process for the company's Non-Readily Realisable Assets (NRRA) and emerged as the successful bidder. Subsequently, pursuant to an auction notice issued in May 2025 for the sale of the corporate debtor as a going concern, he participated in the e-auction and emerged as the highest bidder with an offer of Rs. 1.657 crore.
After Choudhary paid the entire sale consideration along with applicable interest, the liquidator confirmed the sale in September 2025. The liquidator also agreed that the NRRA would form part of the corporate debtor acquired by Choudhary.
Choudhary argued that the liquidation framework recognises the sale of a corporate debtor as a going concern as a method of business revival. He contended that the objectives of revival and value maximisation could not be achieved effectively without granting the successful purchaser the reliefs, concessions and exemptions sought.
The liquidator submitted that the sale process complied with the IBC and the applicable liquidation regulations.
The Income Tax Department opposed the application, arguing that the Income-tax Act, 1961, does not empower authorities to issue blanket orders extinguishing income-tax liabilities, Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) liabilities or other statutory obligations.
It further submitted that Section 79(2)(c), which provides for the carry-forward and set-off of losses following a change in shareholding, applies only when a resolution plan receives approval. Since no resolution plan had been approved in the present case, Choudhary could not claim this benefit.
The Department also maintained that it could continue proceedings under the Income-tax Act as an operational creditor.
The Tribunal accepted the Department's objections, observing that a going-concern sale during liquidation does not constitute a successful resolution process. It noted that the corporate debtor had remained in liquidation for over six years and that the sale had not generated any identifiable benefit or enhanced value for creditors.
It held that granting blanket concessions could prejudice the interests of operational creditors, particularly the Income Tax Department, which had expressly opposed the reliefs sought.
Further, the Bench noted that no appropriate valuation had established whether the asset carried goodwill warranting such concessions. Further, the liquidator had not obtained the NCLT's prior approval for conducting a going-concern sale several years after the liquidation order.
It held that the transaction was required to be treated as a slump sale and that the applicant was not entitled to blanket concessions or exemptions.
Accordingly, the NCLT rejected the application.
For Applicants: Advocates Dheeraj Garg and Harshvardhan Nasra
For Respondents: Advocate Monaal J. Davawala; Advocate Aman A. Mir