IBC Default Date, Not NPA Classification, Triggers Insolvency Against Personal Guarantor: NCLT Allahabad
The Allahabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has held that insolvency proceedings against a personal guarantor under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), are triggered by the date of default and not the date on which the lender classifies the borrower's account as a Non-Performing Asset (NPA).
A Bench of Judicial Member Praveen Gupta and Technical Member Ashish Verma observed that the two dates represent distinct concepts. It held that the cause of action under the IBC arises from the default itself, not the subsequent NPA classification.
"it is observed that the 'Date of Default' and 'Date of NPA' are distinct concepts. The cause of action under the IBC is triggered by the 'default' and not by the NPA classification." , the tribunal observed.
The application was filed by ICICI Bank against Divya Singh, personal guarantor to Ossify Industries Private Limited, seeking initiation of the Personal Insolvency Resolution Process.
The Bank had sanctioned cash credit facilities of ₹10.60 crore to the company under a Credit Arrangement Letter and Facility Agreement dated September 24, 2021. At the company's request, the credit limit was subsequently reduced to ₹4.60 crore through a revised arrangement dated December 22, 2023. Its duration was modified again on February 9, 2024.
To secure these facilities, Divya Singh executed a Deed of Guarantee on 24 September 2021, undertaking joint and several liability for repayment of all amounts due from the Corporate Debtor.
The Financial Creditor alleged that the Corporate Debtor committed defaults in repayment of the credit facilities, resulting in the account being classified as NPA on February 15, 2024. Although part-payments aggregating approximately Rs 97.92 lakh were made thereafter, substantial dues remained outstanding.
Consequently, the Bank issued a composite Loan Recall Notice and Invocation of Personal Guarantee on April 29 2024, followed by a SARFAESI demand notice on May 24, 2024, and later filed recovery actions before the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT).
When the outstanding dues remained unpaid, a demand notice under the Personal Guarantor Insolvency Rules was issued on 27 February 2025. Since no payment was forthcoming, the Financial Creditor filed the present Section 95 application.
Following the filing of the application, the Tribunal appointed Anil Kohli as Resolution Professional (RP). After filing a report under Section 99 of the Code, the RP recommended admission of the application and initiation of PIRP against the Personal Guarantor.
The Personal Guarantor argued that the demand notice had allegedly been issued to another individual instead of the Respondent, rendering the application defective. It was also contended that the RP had failed to independently verify the claim and instead had mechanically relied upon the figures and dates provided by the Financial Creditor.
The Respondent further pointed out an alleged inconsistency between the date of default mentioned in the application, namely 2 January 2024, and the NPA classification date of 15 February 2024.
The Tribunal on the issue of limitation held that the application had been filed well within three years from the invocation of the guarantee and was therefore maintainable.
On the dispute regarding default, the Tribunal drew a distinction between the date of default and the date of NPA classification. It observed that a default occurs when a debt becomes due and remains unpaid, whereas NPA classification happens when it ceases to generate income for the bank, as governed by RBI norms.
The Bench observed that the NPA classification ordinarily always occurs after the date of default. The Tribunal, relying on various judgments, noted that both of them are distinct concepts and that the NPA date could not override the actual date of default. Relying on the authenticated NeSL record, the Tribunal concluded that default by the Corporate Debtor stood conclusively established.
The Bench further noted that the Financial Creditor had validly invoked the guarantee and that the Personal Guarantor had failed to make payment despite service of the relevant notices. It also rejected the objection regarding the demand notice after finding that any deficiency had been cured through a supplementary affidavit demonstrating service upon the guarantor.
Accordingly, the NCLT admitted the application, initiated the Personal Insolvency Resolution Process against Divya Singh and imposed a moratorium.
For Applicants: Advocate Ankit Yadav; Advocates Abhinav Mathur, Gourav Asati & Ishita Arora for RP
For Respondents: Advocates Nidish Gupta & Sahil Yadav