The Karnataka High Court has observed that the NCLT's failure to anticipate the withdrawal of insolvency proceedings initiated by another creditor could attract the principle that a court's mistake prejudicing a party may warrant recall of its order.

The court, comprising Justice T.P. Vivekananda, made the observation while hearing a challenge by Shree Basaveshwar Sugars Limited to the restoration of an insolvency petition filed by the Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Limited (IREDA).

IREDA had approached the NCLT under the Insolvency Code, seeking the initiation of CIRP against the company over dues of ₹178.25 crore. While the petition was pending, the company proposed a one-time settlement of ₹117.35 crore, which IREDA accepted through a sanction letter dated November 17, 2023.

Meanwhile, the NCLT admitted Canara Bank's insolvency petition against the company on January 10, 2024. The next day, it disposed of IREDA's petition, allowing the agency to lodge its claim in Canara Bank's CIRP.

However, the company subsequently entered into an OTS with Canara Bank, and those insolvency proceedings were withdrawn on February 16, 2024. IREDA was consequently unable to lodge its claim in that CIRP.

IREDA then sought recall of the NCLT's January 11, 2024 order and restoration of its petition. The NCLT allowed the application on November 14, 2024.

Before the High Court, the company relied on the Supreme Court's judgment in Budhia Swain v. Gopinath Deb, which recognised that a court or tribunal could recall an order in certain circumstances, including where the court itself commits a mistake that prejudices a party.

The High Court observed, "Though the circumstances as stated in the judgment relied upon by the petitioner do not specifically exist in the present case, however, the circumstances which is cited above i.e. there has been a mistake of the Court prejudicing a party could be applied to the present case."

The court noted that when the NCLT disposed of IREDA's petition, it had permitted the agency to lodge its claim in the CIRP initiated by Canara Bank. However, the NCLT had not anticipated that those proceedings could subsequently end following an OTS between the company and the bank. Neither had IREDA sought liberty to revive its petition nor had the NCLT granted such liberty.

The High Court, however, declined to examine the merits of the company's challenge, holding that it had an alternative remedy of appeal before the NCLAT under Section 61 of the IBC.

It left open the questions of whether the NCLT had jurisdiction to entertain IREDA's recall application and whether the application was barred by limitation. The Court said the company could raise these issues in an appeal before the NCLAT.

The writ petition was accordingly dismissed, with liberty to the company to approach the NCLAT. The Court also allowed it to seek exclusion of the time spent pursuing the writ petition under Section 14 of the Limitation Act.

The interim protection granted earlier was extended by three weeks to enable the company to approach the NCLAT and seek interim relief. The Court clarified that all contentions were kept open and that the NCLAT should not be influenced by its observations.

For Petitioner: C.K. Nanda Kumar, Senior Counsel, along with Shyam Sundar H.V.

For IREDA: Additional Solicitor General K. Arvind Kamath, along with Dhanya Kesari Rao Gurpur.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Shree Basaveshwar Sugars Limited v. Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency LimitedCase Number :  W.P. No. 30901 of 2024CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 241