The Ahmedabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) on 18 November declined to dissolve Naturell (India) Private Limited under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), after finding discrepancies in its liquidation records and unresolved issues concerning statutory liabilities and distribution of its business undertaking.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Shammi Khan and Technical Member Sanjeev Sharma held that a company cannot be dissolved under Sections 59(7) and 59(8) of the IBC unless the Tribunal is satisfied that its affairs have been completely wound up and its assets liquidated in accordance with law. It said:
“Having considered the material available on record, we find that the treatment of the EPFO claim, reconciliation of Form H, verification of pending statutory proceedings and justification for distribution of the Business Undertaking require further clarification and supporting documentary evidence.”
Dilipkumar Natvarlal Jagad, the voluntary liquidator of Naturell (India), filed the application seeking dissolution under Sections 59(7) and 59(8) of the IBC. Incorporated in 1991, the company was a wholly owned subsidiary of Zydus Wellness Limited (ZWL) and manufactured and sold nutrition bars, protein cookies, protein chips and other health-food products under the brands 'Ritebite Max Protein' and 'Ritebite'.
The company's Board approved voluntary liquidation on 24 June 2025. Subsequently, its shareholders approved the liquidation and appointed Jagad as liquidator. Creditors representing 78.37% of the debt value also consented to the process.
The liquidator submitted that he had opened a dedicated Voluntary Liquidation Bank Account with ICICI Bank in compliance with the Voluntary Liquidation Process Regulations (VLP Regulations). Following the public announcement, he received a claim from the company's sole shareholder.
He proposed distributing the company's entire business undertaking, valued at approximately Rs. 399.01 crore, to ZWL, its holding company, on a going-concern basis. After distributing the undertaking and completing the other liquidation activities, he approached the Tribunal seeking dissolution.
The Registrar of Companies reported that no prosecution, complaints, compounding proceedings or other matters were pending against the company. The Income Tax Department's portal also reflected no outstanding demands against the corporate person. The liquidator further submitted that ZWL had assumed the company's liabilities and litigation along with the business undertaking.
The Tribunal noted that its examination of the liquidation records revealed several unresolved issues.
One concern related to an Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) claim of approximately Rs. 14.51 lakh, which the liquidator received after distributing the business undertaking. Although the liquidator maintained that ZWL had subsequently settled the claim, the Tribunal noted that Form H disclosed nil government dues. It therefore sought reconciliation of the disclosure with the liquidation accounts.
The Bench also questioned the distribution of the entire business undertaking to ZWL and required the liquidator to establish how the distribution complied with Regulation 35(3) of the VLP Regulations.
Further, it sought confirmation of the company's shareholding records and clarification regarding the treatment of pending statutory proceedings before tax authorities.
Moreover, the Tribunal identified discrepancies in the liquidation timeline recorded in Form H. These included inconsistencies in the dates of the public announcement and the last date for submission of claims. The form also contained references suggesting that the dissolution application remained under preparation even though the liquidator had already filed it.
Finding that these discrepancies and outstanding issues remained unresolved, the Bench held that it could not record the satisfaction required under Section 59(7) of the IBC to order dissolution under Section 59(8).
Accordingly, the NCLT disposed of the application as premature, without prejudice to the liquidator's right to file a fresh application after rectifying the deficiencies and ensuring compliance with the statutory requirements.
For Applicants: Advocates Sandeep Singhi, Varun Agarwal; Advocate Ashutosh Chouhan for IT Dept