The Mumbai Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), on 19 November, held that a company cannot rely on technical issues with the e-filing portal to justify its failure to cure defects in a reply after becoming aware that the filing had been marked defective.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member K.R. Saji Kumar and Technical Member Anil Raj Chellan allowed an application filed by Magnus Consulting Private Limited seeking recall of an order forfeiting its right to file a reply in proceedings concerning preferential transactions under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. It observed:
“Despite the last opportunity, the Applicant failed to cure the defects and file a defect-free reply within two weeks as ordered. The explanation given by the Applicant that the defects were not reflected on the e-filing portal cannot be accepted as sufficient justification, as the Applicant was aware that its reply had been marked as defective and was required to take appropriate steps to comply with the directions of this Tribunal.”
Magnus Consulting submitted that it had electronically filed its reply within the stipulated time. However, the Tribunal did not take the reply on record because of technical or procedural defects. The company claimed that the e-filing portal did not reflect these defects, preventing it from identifying and rectifying them.
The Tribunal noted that it had marked the reply as defective and, through an order dated 2 September 2025, granted Magnus Consulting a last and final opportunity to file a defect-free reply within two weeks. It held that the company's explanation regarding the portal could not justify its failure to comply with the directions, particularly when it already knew that the reply had been marked defective.
It also noted that the underlying application had been pending since 2023 and that it had granted Magnus Consulting several opportunities to place its reply on record.
However, considering the interim nature of the order and exercising its inherent powers under Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules, 2016, the Bench set aside its order dated 2 December 2025, which had forfeited the company's right to file a reply.
Accordingly, the NCLT directed that Magnus Consulting's reply be accepted, subject to the company ensuring that the filing was reflected as defect-free on the DMS portal within two weeks of uploading the order.
For Applicant: Sr. Adv. Prateek Sekseria a/w Adv. Mayank Samuel a/w Adv. Drumi Nishar i/b Sirius Legal