The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Kolkata, on 20 November held that the principle of res judicata does not bar a resolution professional from seeking a refund before the Tribunal when the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) had dismissed an earlier appeal without deciding the refund claim on merits.

A Bench comprising Judicial Member Labh Singh and Technical Member Rekha Kantilal Shah rejected the Bombay Stock Exchange's (BSE) objection of res judicata and directed it to refund Rs. 39.6 lakh retained towards pre-CIRP liabilities of Spicy Entertainment and Media Limited within two weeks of receiving the order. It said:

“Thus, the objection of the Respondent based on the principle of res judicata cannot be sustained merely on the ground that the Applicant had sought a refund before the Hon'ble SAT. Since the order dated 05.05.2025 does not adjudicate upon the Applicant's entitlement to refund on merits, the Applicant is not barred from filing the present Application.”

Spicy Entertainment's shares were delisted by BSE's Delisting Committee on 12 July 2024. The company approached SAT on 8 November 2024, seeking to challenge the delisting. Meanwhile, the Tribunal admitted the company into the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) on 5 November 2024.

With the approval of the Committee of Creditors, the resolution professional pursued the appeal to explore the possibility of restoring the company's listing status. For this purpose, the resolution professional paid an aggregate Rs. 49.6 lakh towards standard operating procedure fines, revocation application processing fees and reinstatement fees.

SAT dismissed the appeal on 5 May 2025 without adjudicating the matter on merits. BSE subsequently refunded Rs. 9.94 lakh towards reinstatement fees but declined to return the remaining amount.

The resolution professional then approached the NCLT seeking a refund of the balance amount. BSE opposed the application, contending that the earlier proceedings before SAT barred the resolution professional from seeking the same relief again.

The Tribunal rejected this objection, observing that SAT had not adjudicated the Corporate Debtor's entitlement to a refund on merits. It held that the dismissal of the appeal without such an adjudication did not prevent the resolution professional from approaching the NCLT.

It also held that BSE could not appropriate amounts towards the Corporate Debtor's pre-CIRP liabilities during the moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. It observed that the moratorium protects the Corporate Debtor's assets and prevents creditors from recovering their dues outside the insolvency resolution process.

Although BSE had a lawful claim against the Corporate Debtor, the Bench required it to submit its claim to the resolution professional for verification instead of adjusting the amount towards its dues.

Accordingly, the NCLT directed BSE to refund the remaining Rs. 39.6 lakh retained towards the Corporate Debtor's pre-CIRP liabilities within two weeks of receiving the order.

For the Resolution Professional: Advocates Kiran Sharma and Meenakshi Manot

For BSE: Advocates Anunoy Basu and Soham Sen

Tags:    
Case Title :  DEEPAK SARUPARIA, Resolution Professional of Spicy Entertainment and Media Limited Versus BOMBAY STOCK EXCHANGE LIMITEDCase Number :  I.A. (I.B.C) 1678/KB/2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz NCLT (MUM) 1164