The Karnataka High Court allowed Vaishnavi Tractors, a family-run tractor dealership, another opportunity to establish the genuineness of its transactions after finding sufficient bona fides in its explanation for not responding to the show cause notice.
Justice B.M. Shyam Prasad has held that a taxpayer's bona fide failure to respond to GST proceedings, arising from a mistaken belief that the authorities had already dealt with the relevant tax period, can justify restoration of the proceedings. The Bench said:
“The petitioner's bona fides are considered in the amalgam of the afore two sets of circumstances. If the petitioner, who did not have the assistance of dedicated or specialised tax personnel, has not participated in the proceedings under a mistaken belief that the subject Show Cause Notice relating to the tax period which is already seized of by the authorities and which now stand dropped, this Court is of the view that bona fides are brought out justifying an interference for restoration.”
Vaishnavi Tractors challenged an adjudication order dated 22 December 2025, which the authorities passed under Section 73 of the GST Act for FY 2021-22. It also challenged the summary of the order in Form GST DRC-07 dated 23 December 2025 and a garnishee notice in Form GST DRC-13 dated 9 September 2026.
The dispute arose from the allegation that the dealership had failed to reverse Input Tax Credit (ITC) corresponding to credit notes issued by the tractor manufacturer. The department sought to recover the resulting tax along with interest and penalty.
The same dispute had arisen for earlier financial years, from 2017-18 to 2020-21. The dealership had relied on a clarification dated 7 March 2019 concerning ITC reversal where manufacturers issued credit notes.
The Court noted that the authorities had rejected the dealership's reliance on the clarification for FY 2017-18 and had recently dismissed its rectification application. The dealership would have to pursue the statutory first appeal against that rejection. However, the authorities had accepted its reliance on the clarification for FY 2019-20 and FY 2020-21 and dropped the proceedings for those years.
For FY 2021-22, the dealership did not respond to either the intimation in Form GST DRC-01A or the show cause notice in Form GST DRC-01.
Before the Bench, the dealership explained that it was a family-run business without dedicated or specialised tax personnel. It had mistakenly believed that the notices concerned earlier financial years, for which the authorities had either dropped the proceedings or the dealership had filed the necessary appeals. This misunderstanding led it to inadvertently miss the opportunity to respond.
Its counsel sought another opportunity to present the dealership's case before the tax authorities, particularly because the authorities had already dropped proceedings for two earlier financial years on the basis of the clarification.
The Court considered the explanation alongside the outcome of the proceedings for FY 2019-20 and FY 2020-21. It found that the dealership's lack of specialised tax personnel and its mistaken belief that the authorities had already dealt with the relevant tax period sufficiently established its bona fides to warrant restoration.
It permitted the dealership to submit documents establishing the genuineness of the transactions, along with a certified copy of the order, by 11 December 2026. It directed the second respondent to consider the documents and conclude the proceedings through a reasoned order.
Accordingly, the High Court quashed the adjudication order and restored the proceedings, subject to the dealership depositing 10% of the tax demanded by 30 November 2026.
For the Petitioner: Madhu H.S., assisted by Tanmayee Rajkumar.
For the Respondents: Jyothi M. Maradi, High Court Government Pleader.