Image by Ziaa Rizvi

The Allahabad High Court has held that mentioning “N.A.” against the date, time and venue of personal hearing in a show cause notice issued under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, vitiates the proceedings for violation of the principles of natural justice.

Justice Vikas Budhwar held,

“Plainly and simply, the entire controversy boils down to a contingency wherein whether non-affording of opportunity of personal hearing would make the impugned orders vitiated or not. The answer to the same is simple, "Yes". Pertinently, once the show cause notice indicated the date, time and venue of personal hearing as "N.A.", then it partakes a character tantamounting to creating a situation whereby date, time and venue has to be fixed so as to enable the assessee to put forward his case.”

The petitioner, a registered dealer under the GST Act, 2017, was issued a show cause notice under Section 73 on February 23, 2023, for the period July 2017 to March 2018, calling for a reply by March 25, 2023. The columns specifying the date, time and venue of personal hearing were marked “N.A.”.

A subsequent notice granted the petitioner further time to submit its reply. Reminder No. 1 was issued on June 6, 2023, fixing June 12 as the reply date, followed by Reminder No. 2 dated August 29, 2023, fixing August 30. Both reminders again carried “N.A.” against the particulars of personal hearing.

An order under Section 73 was passed on September 1, 2023. The petitioner's appeal, filed on February 2, 2024, was rejected on February 14, 2024, by the Additional Commissioner Grade-II (Appeal), Varanasi, on the ground of delay. Both orders were challenged before the High Court.

The petitioner's counsel argued that the orders violated the principles of natural justice. It was submitted that an assessee has a legal and vested right to a personal hearing and that the petitioner had been deprived of this opportunity. Counsel also contended that the appeal, though filed belatedly, had been rejected through a non-speaking order.

Opposing the petition, the State's counsel submitted that the petitioner could have appeared and sought a personal hearing. He also pointed out that the appeal had been filed with delay.

The High Court held that once the show cause notice specified “N.A.” against the date, time and venue of personal hearing, the authorities were required to fix these particulars to enable the assessee to present its case.

“Here in the present case the incorporation of the word NA in front of the column Date, time and venue of personal hearing itself vitiates the order as it is a clear-cut classic case of violation of principles of natural justice,” the court observed.

Accordingly, the High Court quashed the September 1, 2023 order passed under Section 73 and the February 14, 2024 appellate order. It remitted the matter to the original authority to pass a fresh order.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Digital Universe v. State of Uttar Pradesh and 2 othersCase Number :  WRIT TAX No. - 4290 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC(ALL) 96