GST | Same-Day Reply Deadline & Personal Hearing In Show Cause Notice Invalidates Proceedings: Allahabad High Court
The Allahabad High Court has set aside an order passed under Section 73 of the Uttar Pradesh Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 where the show cause notice called upon the assessee to file its reply and to attend the personal hearing on one and the same date. The Court held that the proceedings had gone wrong from that stage onwards and remitted the matter for a fresh order.
Justice Vikas Budhwar held
“Thus, the irregularity crept from this stage itself.”
The petitioner, a partnership firm registered under the Act and engaged in the business of Mentha Oil, purchased goods worth Rs. 55,26,000/- from Vishnu Traders on January 18, 2021, and availed input tax credit of Rs. 6,63,120/-. The supplier's registration was cancelled suo motu with effect from April 9, 2021.
The Deputy Commissioner, State Tax, Sector-1, Budaun, issued an intimation in Form GST DRC-01A dated September 8, 2021, under Section 73(5)/74(5) read with Rule 142(1A) of the GST Rules, requiring the petitioner to submit objections by September 14, 2021. The department proposed to disallow ITC of Rs. 6,63,120/- by invoking Section 16(2)(c) of the Act. The petitioner submitted a reply to the intimation.
A show cause notice under Section 73 followed on October 26, 2021, fixing November 10, 2021, both as the deadline for submitting a reply and as the date for personal hearing. The Deputy Commissioner subsequently passed an order on January 4, 2022.
According to the petitioner, it learnt of the order only in December 2025 and filed an appeal on January 3, 2026. The Additional Commissioner Grade-II (Appeals-I), State Tax, Bareilly, rejected the appeal on April 30, 2026, on the ground of delay. Both orders were challenged before the High Court.
Counsel for the petitioner argued that the procedure adopted by the assessing authority was contrary to Office Memo No. 1406 dated November 12, 2024, issued by the Commissioner, Commercial Tax, and relied on its interpretation in Mahaveer Trading Company v. Deputy Commissioner, State Tax and Another. It was further argued that the doctrine of merger would not apply where the appeal had been dismissed on the ground of delay, and that the circumstances justified invocation of the High Court's jurisdiction under Article 226 despite the absence of a separate delay condonation application.
Standing Counsel submitted that the petitioner had not actively participated before the assessing authority and had not filed a delay condonation application in appeal. However, he did not dispute that under Mahaveer Trading Company, the date of personal hearing could not be the same as the date for submitting the reply, which had to precede the hearing.
The Court observed that the issue was no longer res integra. In Mahaveer Trading Company, a Division Bench had held that fixing the personal hearing on the same date by which the reply to the show cause notice was due was non est and that the practice had to be discontinued. The date for submitting the reply had to precede the date of personal hearing.
With the petitioner agreeing to a condition being imposed and Standing Counsel seeking a time-bound direction, the Court set aside the order dated January 4, 2022, as well as the appellate order dated April 30, 2026, passed under Section 107 of the Act. It remitted the matter to the Deputy Commissioner, State Tax, Sector-1, Budaun, for a fresh order.
The petitioner was directed to submit its reply by November 18, 2026. The authority was directed to fix a personal hearing in the second week of December 2026 and pass an order thereafter in accordance with law. The benefit of the order was made conditional on the petitioner depositing Rs. 5,000/- as costs by November 13, 2026.
Clarifying that its observations were not on the merits of the case, the court recorded,
"The orders so passed today on the basis of the consent of the parties, thus, it would not be treated to be a precedent."
The petition was disposed of.