Parent Company's Guarantee For Subsidiary's Loan Is Taxable Under GST Even Without Consideration: Delhi HC
The Delhi High Court in Tuesday held that a corporate guarantee furnished by a parent or group company to secure loans obtained by its subsidiary or related entity constitutes a taxable supply of services under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, even when no fee or consideration is charged.
The Division Bench of Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar observed that when a holding company provides a guarantee for its subsidiary's borrowing, it assumes the risk of the subsidiary's default and extends its own creditworthiness to enable the subsidiary to obtain financing.
"A corporate guarantee furnished by a holding/group company to a banking company or financial institution, for the borrowings of a related person, is a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I of the Act of 2017, even where no consideration is charged," it observed.
The court explained that the service lies in the assumption of the related person's default risk and the consequent extension of the guarantor's creditworthiness. It further clarified that the recipient of such service is the subsidiary or related company on whose behalf the guarantee is furnished, rather than the bank or financial institution.
The ruling came in a batch of petitions filed by Sterlite Power Transmission Limited, ReNew Private Limited, Jindal Stainless Limited, Azure Power India and several other companies challenging the applicability of GST to corporate guarantees and the valuation mechanism prescribed under Rule 28(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017.
The dispute concerned whether a corporate guarantee provided by a holding company to a financial institution for the borrowings of its subsidiary could be treated as a supply of services under Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017.
Petitioners argued that providing such guarantees was merely a shareholder activity undertaken to protect the holding company's investment and did not amount to a supply of services. They submitted that a holding company does not ordinarily provide guarantees as a commercial service for profit, unlike banks that issue guarantees in exchange for commission.
It was further contended that where no consideration was charged, a corporate guarantee could not attract GST. The petitioners relied on decisions under the earlier service tax regime, including the Supreme Court's decision in Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise v. Edelweiss Financial Services Ltd.
The Revenue opposed these submissions and argued that corporate guarantees involved the assumption of financial risk and constituted a supply of services to the subsidiary.
The High Court observed that three distinct legal relationships exist in such transactions: the loan agreement between the subsidiary and the lender, the guarantee between the holding company and the lender, and the relationship between the holding company and the subsidiary under which the former assumes the risk of the latter's default.
It held that although the guarantee is formally executed in favour of the lender, the holding company provides a service to the subsidiary by making its creditworthiness available to support the borrowing.
"What the guarantor/holding company provides is its own creditworthiness. It places its balance sheet behind the borrowings of the subsidiary and, from the very moment the guarantee is executed, assumes the risk of the subsidiary's default," the Court observed.
It explained that this assumption of risk constituted a real financial commitment, as it affected the guarantor's own capacity to borrow and furnish further guarantees. It noted that such guarantees enabled subsidiaries to obtain loans that they might otherwise be unable to secure, or to obtain financing on more favourable terms.
The Court therefore held that something of economic value passed from the holding company to the subsidiary, satisfying the definition of services under Section 2(102) of the CGST Act.
Rejecting the argument that corporate guarantees were merely shareholder activities, the Court observed that the motive behind a transaction did not determine its legal character for GST purposes.
It held that a guarantee furnished to secure financing for a subsidiary's project, in which the holding company had a commercial interest, was an activity connected with or incidental to its business under Section 2(17) of the Act.
The Court also rejected the distinction sought to be drawn between bank guarantees and corporate guarantees. It observed that although banks ordinarily charged commission for providing guarantees, the essential nature of the activity remained the assumption of another person's financial risk.
Absence Of Consideration Does Not Exclude GST
The court also examined whether a corporate guarantee could be taxed when the holding company received no payment from its subsidiary. It noted that under the earlier service tax regime, consideration formed part of the definition of a taxable service. However, the CGST Act, 2017 adopted a different statutory framework.
Section 7(1)(c), read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, expressly treats supplies between related persons made in the course or furtherance of business as taxable supplies even when no consideration is charged.
The Court consequently distinguished the Supreme Court's decision in Edelweiss Financial Services, observing that the ruling concerned the definition of service under the earlier legislation and did not govern the GST regime.
It held that the absence of consideration, or clauses in guarantee deeds prohibiting the payment of fees or commission, did not defeat the levy of GST.
The Court further clarified that the subsidiary was the recipient of the service under Section 2(93)(c) of the Act because the credit support was rendered for its benefit. Although the lender was the promisee under the guarantee contract, it was the subsidiary whose borrowing was secured and whose access to finance was facilitated.
The Court also rejected the argument that corporate guarantees were excluded from GST as actionable claims or securities. It held that the subsidiary received credit support rather than an actionable claim, while a corporate guarantee did not qualify as a security within the meaning of the relevant provisions of the CGST Act.
The High Court also read down Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, which prescribed a deemed valuation of 1% of the guaranteed amount per annum. It held that treating the prescribed valuation as an inflexible minimum was arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. The Court permitted suppliers to establish a lower open market value through cogent and verifiable evidence.
For the Petitioners: Senior Advocate Balbir Singh; Advocates Kumar Visalaksh, Rahul Khurana, Udit Jain, Arihant Tater, Ajitesh Dayal Singh, Pranav Bansal, Vibhor Sharma, Disha Jham, Vedant Kohli and Karan Sachdev.
For the Respondents: Standing Panel Counsel Tanvi Nigam for the Union of India; Central Government Standing Counsel Shashank Dixit, along with Advocates Kunal Raj, Shagun Shahi Chugh and Rimpy Rohilla; Additional Solicitor General N. Venkatraman, along with Senior Standing Counsel Atul Tripathi and Advocates Akshay Sagar, Shubham Mishra and Gaurav Mani Tripathi.