Omitting Taxable Receipts From GST Returns Amounts To Wilful Suppression, Attracts Penalty: GSTAT Bengaluru
The Bengaluru Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) has held that deliberately omitting taxable receipts from statutory GST returns amounts to wilful suppression of facts, even if the receipts are recorded in the taxpayer's financial statements.
The tribunal observed that such omissions can attract a penalty under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017.
A coram comprising Judicial Member Srikanth Venkatraman and Technical Member Sudha Kokaru ruled,
"Concealing taxable receipts inside private P&L statements or internal ledgers while omitting them from statutory GST returns constitutes active, wilful suppression under Explanation 2."
The case concerned Sadhana Enviro Engineering Services, which provides operation and maintenance services for desilting machines used in sewer cleaning. It also supplies sanitation machinery and manpower to government departments and urban local bodies.
The GST Department audited the taxpayer's records for the period from July 2017 to March 2020. It found an outward-tax liability of ₹56.39 lakh and a separate input tax credit (ITC) discrepancy of ₹1.20 lakh.
The outward-tax liability included ₹34.69 lakh declared in GSTR-1 but not paid through GSTR-3B. The Department also found that the taxpayer had recorded certain taxable receipts and write-off amounts in its profit and loss account but had not disclosed them in its statutory GST returns. These omissions formed the basis of a further liability of ₹19.02 lakh.
Following the audit observations, the taxpayer paid the principal outward tax of ₹56.39 lakh through DRC-03 challans between November 2022 and January 2023. It also paid ₹10,000 towards penalty but did not pay the applicable interest or the full penalty. The Department subsequently issued a show cause notice under Section 74 of the CGST Act.
The adjudicating authority confirmed the tax and ITC demands, along with interest and penalties under Section 74.
The taxpayer appealed. The First Appellate Authority partly allowed its appeal. It dropped the penalty on the ₹34.69 lakh liability, holding that the amount had been disclosed in GSTR-1 and GSTR-9. It also converted the proceedings concerning the ₹19.02 lakh liability from Section 74 to Section 73 and imposed a reduced penalty of ₹2.10 lakh.
However, the First Appellate Authority retained a separate penalty of ₹2.68 lakh under Section 74 for an unreported write-off differential. It also modified the ITC demand and imposed a reduced penalty of ₹40,000 under Section 73.
The Department challenged the dropping and reduction of penalties on the ₹34.69 lakh and ₹19.02 lakh liabilities before GSTAT.
The tribunal examined whether the taxpayer's disclosure of transactions in its financial statements, and its subsequent declaration of additional liability in GSTR-9, could protect it from proceedings under Section 74.
Referring to the Andhra Pradesh High Court's decision in Sriba Nirman Company v. Joint Commissioner (Appeals), which was affirmed by the Supreme Court, the tribunal observed that every instance of non-payment of tax cannot automatically be treated as fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. The authorities must examine whether the record establishes wilful suppression with an intent to evade tax.
Applying this principle, the tribunal distinguished between the two liabilities.
In respect of the ₹19.02 lakh liability, the taxpayer had recorded taxable receipts, including amounts reflected in its profit and loss account and receipts from Mahindra & Mahindra, but had omitted them from GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B.
The tribunal found that the taxpayer declared the additional liability in GSTR-9 only after the audit team began verifying its records and confronted it with the financial statements and Form 26AS particulars.
It held that the disclosure could not be treated as voluntary compliance merely because it was made before the show cause notice was issued. The tribunal concluded that the omission of taxable receipts from statutory returns, followed by disclosure after audit intervention, amounted to wilful suppression under Explanation 2 to Section 74.
The tribunal took a different view of the ₹34.69 lakh liability. The taxpayer had already declared the corresponding outward supplies in GSTR-1, which was available on the Department's portal. The tribunal therefore found that there was no suppression of turnover in respect of this amount.
However, the taxpayer had not paid the applicable interest along with the principal tax. The tribunal held that payment of both tax and interest was necessary to claim a waiver of penalty under Section 73. It therefore restored the penalty despite finding that Section 74 was not applicable to this liability.
The tribunal also rejected the taxpayer's argument that the proceedings had concluded under the amnesty scheme under Section 128A of the CGST Act. It found that the waiver order in Form GST SPL-05 covered only the residual ₹40,000 penalty relating to the Section 73 demands. It did not cover the penalties challenged by the Department in the present appeal.
Accordingly, the tribunal allowed the Department's appeal. It restored the 100% penalty of ₹19.02 lakh under Section 74 and imposed a penalty of ₹3.59 lakh under Section 73 on the ₹34.69 lakh liability.
For Authorities: Venugopal Naidu and Rahul, CGST
For Taxpayer: Mohammed Shabbir