On 12 November, the Chandigarh Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) held that authorities cannot confiscate goods under Section 130 of the GST Act on the basis of alleged wrongful Input Tax Credit (ITC) claims on earlier purchases without establishing a connection between those purchases and the goods detained during transportation.

A Bench of Judicial Member Jatinder Pal Singh and Technical Member Pradeep Kumar Goel allowed an appeal filed by R.K. Enterprises against the confiscation of its goods and vehicle. It observed:

“We are of the view that in the absence of any evidence that the goods which were confiscated were offending goods, confiscation cannot be justified.”

The case arose when GST officials intercepted a consignment of aluminium scrap belonging to R.K. Enterprises during transportation. The driver produced the tax invoice, e-way bill, goods receipt and weighment slip accompanying the consignment.

However, the Department detained the consignment after questioning the genuineness of R.K. Enterprises' earlier purchases and the ITC claimed on those transactions. It alleged that some of the firms from which R.K. Enterprises had purchased goods were non-existent and that certain suppliers in the earlier supply chain had not paid tax to the Government.

Relying on these allegations, the Department confiscated the goods and vehicle and imposed a fine and penalty. The First Appellate Authority upheld the order, following which R.K. Enterprises approached the GSTAT.

Before the Tribunal, R.K. Enterprises argued that the consignment was accompanied by all documents required under GST law. It contended that allegations concerning earlier purchases could not justify confiscation of a separate consignment being transported for supply to a customer.

The Tribunal noted that the Department had not identified any discrepancy in the invoice, e-way bill or other documents accompanying the detained goods. It observed that the allegations concerned earlier purchases and not the consignment intercepted during transportation.

It clarified that the issue before it was whether the confiscation of the goods and vehicle was legally justified, and not whether R.K. Enterprises had correctly claimed ITC on its earlier purchases. It also noted that the Department had neither sought reversal of the disputed ITC in its show cause notice nor ordered its recovery in the original order.

Referring to Section 130 of the GST Act, the Bench observed that confiscation requires the establishment of a violation of the relevant statutory provisions. Since the Department had not established any violation concerning the detained consignment, the mere allegations of wrongful ITC claims on earlier purchases could not justify confiscation.

Further it found that the Department had failed to establish any connection between the earlier purchases on which ITC was allegedly wrongly claimed and the goods confiscated during transportation. It held:

“Even if it is assumed that the Appellant was availing ITC in violation of legal provisions, we are afraid confiscation of the subject goods cannot be justified in the absence of any allegation or evidence in the SCN regarding any nexus between the inward supplies received by the Appellant on which ITC was allegedly wrongly availed and the goods supplied by the Appellant which were detained during transit on 10.11.2022.”

Accordingly, the GSTAT set aside the confiscation of the goods and vehicle under Section 130, as well as the penalty imposed under Section 122. It allowed the appeal and granted consequential relief to R.K. Enterprises.

For the Appellant: Advocates Vikrant Kackria and Ram Niwas.

For the Department: State Tax officials.

Tags:    
Case Title :  R.K. Enterprises v. K S Chahal & Ors.Case Number :  APL/169/CHD/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC(CHD) 89