GST Hearing Notice Disputes Involving Factual Questions Should Be Raised In Appeal, Not Writ: Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has held that disputes concerning service of hearing notices and grant of personal hearing in Goods and Services Tax (GST) proceedings, which require examination of disputed facts and departmental records, should be examined by the statutory appellate authority rather than in writ proceedings.
The Division Bench of Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar observed,
"Such an exercise would be more appropriately undertaken by the statutory Appellate Authority, which is empowered to examine the relevant records and adjudicate the objections raised by the respective Petitioners."
The Court was hearing petitions challenging GST demands confirmed against Petitioners over allegations of wrongful availment and utilisation of Input Tax Credit (ITC).
The dispute arose from an investigation into alleged bogus firms issuing invoices without actual supply of goods.
Petitioners contended that despite requesting a personal hearing, no effective opportunity was afforded to them. They also disputed the service of notices fixing hearing dates, arguing that the authorities could not resort to affixing notices on the notice board without first establishing that other prescribed modes of service were impracticable.
The Revenue however submitted that hearing opportunities had been provided and that the petitioners could challenge the adjudication orders through statutory appeals under Section 107 of the CGST Act.
The High Court noted that Section 75(4) of the CGST Act requires an opportunity of hearing where a written request is made or an adverse decision is contemplated.
It further observed that Section 169 prescribes the procedure for service of notices, including service through registered post or speed post with acknowledgement due. Affixation on the notice board can be resorted to only in the circumstances contemplated under the provision.
However, the Court held that determining whether the petitioners were properly informed of the hearings would require examination of dispatch records, postal acknowledgements and other departmental material.
The Court also noted that 14 appeals arising from the same adjudication order were already pending before the appellate authority.
"Although the Petitioners have invoked the principles of natural justice, the controversy essentially concerns whether their written requests for personal hearing were duly considered and whether the notices fixing such hearings were dispatched and served in the manner prescribed under Section 169 of the CGST Act," the Court observed.
Accordingly, the Court declined to examine the factual controversies in writ jurisdiction and disposed of the petitions, granting liberty to the petitioners to pursue statutory appeals.
For Petitioner: Advocate S. Sunil
For Respondents: Anushree Narain, SSC with Advocate Aourv Yadav