The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Ahmedabad, has recently held that 100% approval of a resolution plan by the Committee of Creditors (CoC) does not dispense with the statutory scrutiny required under Section 30(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
It remitted a resolution plan for reconsideration over discrepancies in asset valuations and unexplained NIL valuation of receivables.
“The approval of the Resolution Plan by 100% voting share of the CoC does not dispense with the statutory scrutiny required under Section 30(2) of the Code. The Adjudicating Authority cannot substitute its commercial wisdom for that of the CoC. However, where deficiencies requiring reconsideration are noticed, the Resolution Plan may be remitted to the CoC for consideration in accordance with law.” a Bench of Judicial Member Shammi Khan and Technical Member Sanjeev Sharma observed.
The resolution plan submitted by Sushil Shankar Lal Somani and Neelam Sushil Somani proposed Rs. 60 lakh against aggregate financial creditor claims of Rs. 618,94,55,625. The CoC had approved it with 100% voting share.
The tribunal noted that Bank of Baroda had sold the Corporate Debtor's land and building under the SARFAESI Act during 2019-20, before commencement of CIRP. However, details of the sale proceeds and recoveries had not been placed on record.
It also flagged investments in several companies, including Sumeet Industries Limited, and preference shares in Dhanpriya Prints Private Limited.
The tribunal also flagged the valuation of the company's investments and receivables, including advances worth ₹2.89 crore that were assigned NIL value without adequate reasons. It noted discrepancies in the fair and liquidation valuations and sought details of the company's investments and an earlier asset sale by Bank of Baroda.
It directed the Resolution Professional to place these details before the CoC for reconsideration and extended the CIRP by 30 days, until December 20, 2026, to allow the process to be completed.
For Applicant: Amol Vyas, Advocate a.w. Satyendra Prasad Khorania, RP In Person