The Delhi High Court on 19 November returned ten intellectual property infringement suits filed by companies, including Novartis, Dr. Reddy's Laboratories and Mold-Tek Packaging, after finding that the disputes did not establish territorial jurisdiction in Delhi.

Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav held that the mere accessibility of websites, online marketplace listings or allegedly infringing products in Delhi does not confer territorial jurisdiction on the Court. Plaintiffs must establish that a material, integral and substantial part of the cause of action arose within its jurisdiction. The Bench said:

“where lies the material, integral and essential part of the cause of action” and “where the dominant part of the infringement lies”.

The Court was dealing with ten suits involving allegations of patent, design, trademark and copyright infringement, filed by companies including Czech Republic-based První Brněnská Strojírna, German company Gebr. Schmid, Novartis, Dr. Reddy's Laboratories, Mold-Tek Packaging, Nyra Chocolates and Spanish company Sotkon.

In several suits, the plaintiffs sought to establish territorial jurisdiction by relying on defendants' websites, online marketplace listings, alleged offers for sale or individual transactions involving products delivered in Delhi.

The Court found that such connections, without evidence of substantial commercial activity or other material parts of the disputes taking place in Delhi, were insufficient to establish territorial jurisdiction.

In a patent infringement suit filed by German company Gebr. Schmid GMBH against Waaree Energies Ltd. regarding Indian Patent No. 403508 for a flat substrate and solar cell treatment process, the Court observed that the plaintiff was located in Germany, whereas Waaree Energies maintained its registered office in Mumbai, Maharashtra, and a subordinate facility in Surat, Gujarat.

Although the plaintiff sought to establish jurisdiction in Delhi based on interactive website listings and an investigator-facilitated sample delivery, it held that because the core manufacturing activity occurred in Gujarat, the substance and genesis of the dispute lay outside Delhi

Further, the Bench observed that a dispute could not be split into multiple causes of action merely because different activities connected with the alleged infringement occurred in different places. It said courts must identify the place where the material and essential part of the cause of action arose and where the dominant part of the alleged infringement took place.

In another suit, Mold-Tek Packaging alleged that companies based in Surat had copied its patented and registered-design-protected plastic containers and lids. The Court held that the accessibility of websites and product listings on e-marketplaces from Delhi did not establish that the defendants were carrying on business within its jurisdiction. Since the allegedly infringing products were manufactured in Gujarat, the substance and genesis of the dispute lay there.

It also examined a trademark dispute filed by Dr. Reddy's Laboratories over the alleged use of 'DAPLOGIN' for medicines, which the company claimed infringed its 'DAPLO' mark. The pharmaceutical company relied on a purchase made through an online pharmacy and delivered in Delhi.

However, the Bench noted that the transaction was with the online pharmacy and not the defendant itself. It also found no documentary evidence to support the claim that the defendant was selling the products through distributors and chemists in Delhi.

It rejected the argument that a plaintiff could invoke territorial jurisdiction wherever the effects of an alleged infringement were felt.

In a copyright suit filed by Global Music Junction against digital entertainment companies, the Court found that the underlying dispute arose from contractual arrangements between parties based in Mumbai and Patna.

The agreements also contained clauses conferring exclusive jurisdiction on courts in Mumbai. The Bench held that mere accessibility of the plaintiff's content on streaming platforms in Delhi did not establish a cause of action within the Court's jurisdiction.

Moreover, the Bench emphasised that the doctrine of forum conveniens requires courts to examine whether a forum is genuinely suited to adjudicate a dispute, even where some jurisdictional connection exists. A plaintiff does not have an unrestricted right to choose the forum it considers most advantageous.

Accordingly, the High Court returned all ten plaints under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, permitting the plaintiffs to present them before the courts having appropriate territorial jurisdiction.

For Sotkon: Advocates Tanya Varma, Devyani Nath, Ruchika Yadavi, Vivek Shandilya, Hansika Bajaj

For Western Imaginary: Advocates Anshul Goel and Ashok Goel

For Gandhinagar Municipal Corporation: Advocates Praduman Gohil, Ranu Purohit, Vishnu Vardhan

For První Brněnská Strojírna Velká Bíteš: Senior Advocates Sandeep Sethi and Gaurav Miglani with Advocates Sharabh Srivastava, Devesh Aswal, Krishna Gambhir

For Gebr. Schmid: Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak with Advocates Mohan Dewan, N. K. Bhardwaj, Bikash Ghorai, Shyam Nair

For Waaree Energies: Advocate Aasish Somasi

For HLE Glascoat: Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak with Advocates Shantanu Prasahar, Harsh Trivedi, Nilesh Nayak, Yuvraj Singh, Shaurya Chaurasiya

For Sachin Industries: Senior Advocate Rajeshwari H. with Advocates Tahir A. J., Aeshita Marwah

For Mold-Tek Packaging: Advocates Ashutosh Kumar, Vinod Chauhan, Radhika Pareva, Adithya Bhaskaran, Ayush Sharma

Ideal Technoplast: Advocate Sneha Sethia

For Novartis: Advocates Hemant Singh, Abhay Tandon, Ritik Gawali, Kriti

For Global Music Junction: Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak with Advocates Aayush Kevlani, Parkhi Rai, Sidhi Pramodh Rayadu

Nyra Chocolates: Advocates Samrat S. Kang, Swapnil Agrawal

For Dr. Reddy's Laboratories: Advocates Ranjan Narula, Shakti Priyan Nair, Gitanjali Vohra, Aakash Bhamri

For Plusplus Lifesciences: Senior Advocate Rajeshwari H. with Advocates Garima Joshi, Sawami Chothe

For Myown Healthcare: Advocates Surbhi Agarwal, Sumit Kumar

For Ishaanav Nutraceuticals: Advocates Sourabh Gupta, Puneet Yadav, Akshansh Gupta

Tags:    
Case Title :  Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. and connected mattersCase Number :  CS(COMM) 484/202 and connected mattersCITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1271