Kerala High Court Upholds Injunction Against 'ELADI THRILL', Says Common Words Can Become Trademarks
The Kerala High Court on 12 November upheld an interim injunction restraining a Thrissur-based sweets manufacturer from selling chewable candies under the trademark 'ELADI THRILL', in a trademark infringement and passing off dispute involving the ayurvedic products of K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar V.M. dismissed an appeal by Vineetha Suresh Babu and Ameya Sweets against an interim injunction granted by the Additional District Court, Thrissur, in favour of Dr. Rose Mary Wilson and K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala Pvt. Ltd. It held:
“It is by reason of such long use, it has earned reputation and goodwill and acquired a secondary meaning, thereby acquiring a distinctiveness. The appellants have disclosed their turnover and expenses incurred for advertisement for the last 23 years. Admittedly, the mark “ELADI” of the plaintiffs was in use much prior to adoption of the mark “ELADI” by the appellants...”
The plaintiffs instituted the suit alleging trademark infringement and passing off. They claimed that they had sold 'ELADI' chewable tablets and lehyam for cough and cold since 1989 and had built substantial goodwill around the mark. They also alleged that the defendants adopted the deceptively similar mark 'ELADI THRILL' and copied their product's trade dress.
The defendants argued that their candies were registered under Class 30, whereas the plaintiffs' medicinal products fell under Class 5. They also contended that 'ELADI' was descriptive and commonly used in the ayurvedic trade.
Rejecting these arguments, the Court noted that the plaintiffs had established extensive use of the mark since 1989, supported by substantial sales and promotional expenditure. It also observed that the defendants had failed to provide any plausible explanation for adopting the word at a much later stage.
It held that registration under a different trademark class would not, by itself, protect the defendants from an infringement action when the prominent feature of their mark was identical to the plaintiffs' mark.
“Every word can be a trademark,” the Bench observed, adding that the likelihood of confusion must be assessed from the perspective of an ordinary purchaser with imperfect recollection. It also clarified that a trademark proprietor need not initiate proceedings against every insignificant infringer merely to preserve its rights. It further remarked:
“In the instant case, the plaintiffs, both by reason of prior use and subsequent registration, have been able to establish the paramount right and used the mark “ELADI” in respect of its products. Insofar as the argument that the said word is common to the trade, is also not acceptable because a word which may be common, may, by reason of its long and extensive use, become identifiable with the proprietor of the said mark and acquire a secondary meaning.”
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the interim injunction, finding that the defendants had failed to establish any distinguishing feature capable of preventing consumer confusion.
For Appellants: Advocates K.Radhakrishnan Nair, Sajen Thampan, Jinu Samyuktha Padmakumar, Ayoona P. M., Athil Jamal, Ashmy Lal G. and Sarika Krishna A.
For Respondents: Advocates P.Abraham Cherian, Nimmy K. Joseph, Joe Joseph, Jaison S. Rozario, Aravind Varghese, Pooja Jose, V.Varun, Haritha Mohan and Amal John Sabu