The Karnataka High Court has set aside an interim injunction restraining a Mangaluru family firm from using the name “The Children's Corner” in a dispute over the ownership of the business name and goodwill following the dissolution of a family partnership.

A Division Bench comprising Justices D K Singh and H Shanthi Bhushan allowed an appeal filed by the founder's wife, Yashoda N Rai, and son against an injunction granted to his daughter, Nishali Rai, and the erstwhile partnership firm she controls. It said:

“The relief of injunction is discretionary, and it cannot be granted merely on the basis of apprehension when the very right asserted by the applicant is yet to be established...”

Late Narayana T Rai started the business, Children's Corner, around 1981. He later converted it into a partnership with his wife, Yashoda. Their daughter, Nishali, subsequently joined the partnership. Under a partnership deed executed in November 2018, Yashoda held a 40% share in the firm, while Nishali held the remaining 60%.

Following differences between the partners, Nishali issued a notice dissolving the partnership in March 2024. She later alleged that Yashoda and her son had started another business under the name “The Children's Corner” and were using the erstwhile firm's goodwill and stock to mislead customers. The plaintiffs claimed that the original business had an annual turnover of approximately Rs. 5.2 crore.

In July 2026, the Commercial Court made absolute an interim injunction restraining the defendants from using the name “The Children's Corner”. Yashoda and her son challenged the order before the High Court.

The High Court observed that Yashoda's claim that she was the original proprietor and had continued as a partner “cannot be treated as an insignificant defence”. It said Nishali could not claim exclusive ownership of the goodwill merely because she was a partner in the firm.

It noted that an arbitrator was already considering the ownership and valuation of the goodwill, along with the parties' right to use the trade name. The Commercial Court had therefore erred in assuming that the plaintiffs would ultimately establish ownership of the goodwill.

Further, the Bench found that the plaintiffs had failed to establish an exclusive right over the goodwill or identify any customers who had been misled by the defendants' use of the name. They had also failed to explain how that use had harmed their business.

It clarified that the claimed annual turnover, by itself, did not establish Nishali's exclusive entitlement to the goodwill. It also added that granting the injunction would effectively bring the business to a standstill before the parties could establish their respective rights.

Accordingly, the High Court set aside the Commercial Court's order and dismissed the application for interim injunction. It clarified that its observations would not affect the final adjudication of the suit or the pending arbitration.

For Appellants: Advocate K Chandranath Ariga

For Respondents: Advocate Ajay T.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Smt. Yashoda N. Rai & Ors. v. M/s Children Corner & Anr.Case Number :  COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 416 OF 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 239