The Delhi High Court has recently ruled that the trial court's satisfaction that a plea challenging the validity of a registered trade mark is prima facie tenable is not permission to file a rectification petition.

Rather, it is the condition for pursuing the invalidity plea so that it can eventually affect the pending infringement suit and lead to a stay of proceedings.

“The satisfaction of the court trying the suit as to the prima facie tenability of the plea of invalidity is, therefore, not a permission to file a rectification petition. It is the condition upon which the plea of invalidity can be pursued so as to eventually have a bearing on the pending civil suit, and upon which the suit is to be stayed,” Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav ruled.

J.R. Rice India Pvt. Ltd. sued Pawan Kumar Mittal, proprietor of Shree Salasar Dev Basmati House, before the Commercial Court at Tis Hazari, Delhi, on June 23, 2025.

The company alleged that Mittal's use of “KESAR KHAZANA” and “KITCHEN KHAZANA” for rice infringed its registered trade marks “KHAZANA” and “KESARIA” in Class 30 and amounted to passing off.

Mittal challenged the registrations, arguing that the expressions were descriptive, laudatory and commonly used in the rice trade. He pointed to other traders who had used the expressions, some even before the company. He also alleged that the marks had not been put to bona fide use and that material facts were not disclosed when the registrations were obtained.

On January 27, 2026, Mittal applied under Section 124 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, seeking a stay of the suit and orders enabling him to initiate rectification proceedings against the two registrations.

The Commercial Court dismissed his application on October 6, 2026. According to Mittal's counsel, the court reasoned that these objections could have been raised when Mittal applied to register his own mark and that he challenged the company's registrations only after the infringement suit was filed. Counsel also argued that the Commercial Court had devoted only about one and a half pages of its 20-page order to its reasoning and had not examined whether the invalidity plea was prima facie tenable.

Mittal approached the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution, filing separate petitions against the two registrations. The court noted that he had not yet filed any rectification petition. His request for orders enabling him to initiate such proceedings was essentially a request for permission, which the law does not require.

Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Patel Field Marshal Agencies v. P.M. Diesels Ltd., the court reiterated that Section 124 does not require permission from the civil court to initiate rectification proceedings.

It also referred to the Delhi High Court Division Bench ruling in Amrish Aggarwal v. Venus Home Appliances, which held that filing a rectification action does not automatically stay the infringement suit. The trial court must examine the invalidity plea on a prima facie basis and, if it finds that the plea raises a triable issue, stay further proceedings.

The court left open whether any rectification petition filed by Mittal could proceed while the suit was pending and what effect it would have on the proceedings.

Mittal's counsel subsequently sought to withdraw the petitions with liberty to raise all issues at an appropriate stage. The court allowed the request, clarifying that dismissal of his earlier Section 124 application could not, by itself, be the sole reason to decline consideration of a fresh application.

The Commercial Court must consider any such application on its own merits and in accordance with law. The High Court expressed no opinion on the correctness of the Commercial Court's order, the prima facie tenability of the invalidity plea, the validity of the registrations, or the merits of the infringement and passing-off claims.

For Salasar Dev Basmati House: Advocates Ajay Amitabh Suman & Pankaj Kumar

Tags:    
Case Title :  Pawan Kumar Mittal Proprietor of Shree Salasar Dev Basmati House v. J.R. Rice India Pvt. Ltd.Case Number :  CM(M)-IPD 60/2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1255