The Delhi High Court has cancelled a rice trader's 'NAWAZISH' trademark registration, finding that it was phonetically and visually identical to Dunar Foods' earlier 'NAWAJISH' mark and had been dishonestly adopted for identical goods.

Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav observed that Ankit Vats, who trades as AVJK Foods LLP, had offered no plausible explanation for adopting the same distinctive term used by Dunar Foods for rice. The court found that the adoption appeared deliberate when considered against Dunar Foods' longstanding prior use.

Dunar Foods had approached the Court seeking cancellation of the registration obtained by Ankit Vats, who trades as AVJK Foods LLP, for 'NAWAZISH' in Class 30.

Vats had also filed a cross-petition seeking cancellation of Dunar Foods' trademark.

Dunar Foods claimed to have adopted and used 'NAWAJISH' for rice and allied products since 2007. It submitted that Vats applied for the identical mark in June 2017 on a “proposed to be used” basis, despite Dunar Foods' prior registration and use.

Vats argued that he was an honest concurrent user and relied on a device mark featuring the letter 'N'.

He also raised an objection to the maintainability of Dunar Foods' petition in view of proceedings under the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors Act.

Rejecting the objection, the Court said that the proceedings did not prevent Dunar Foods from initiating legal action to protect its intellectual property rights.

On comparing the competing marks and packaging, the Court found them phonetically and visually identical. It said the 'N' device on Vats' packaging did not create any meaningful distinction, particularly since both parties dealt in rice.

The Court also observed that changing the letter 'J' to 'Z' would not help Vats, as both words were pronounced similarly. Such minor variations appeared to have been made “with a view to pass off the plaintiff's goods”, it said.

The Court noted that Dunar Foods had placed material establishing use of the mark since 2007, while Vats had offered no plausible explanation for adopting the same coined term for identical goods. His application, the Court said, appeared designed to ride on the prior user's established reputation.

Accordingly, it cancelled Vats' 'NAWAZISH' registration and dismissed his cross-petition seeking cancellation of Dunar Foods' trademark.

For Dunar Foods: Senior Advocate Swathi Sukumar with Advocates Junaid Alam, S. Nithin, Rishika Aggarwal and Nishant Mattha

For AVJK Foods: Advocates Utsav Jain, Hemant Singh, Urvashi Jain, Aman Bidhuri and Attrey Gupta

Tags:    
Case Title :  Dunar Foods Limited v. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP & Anr.Case Number :  C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 158/2024CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1256