The Madras High Court on 11 November allowed an appeal filed by Skillz Platform Inc. against the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs and remitted the application to a different Patent Controller for fresh consideration.
A Bench of Justice P.B. Balaji held that an amendment to a patent application by withdrawing a method claim and retaining only a system claim warrants fresh consideration of the application in light of the amended claims.
Skillz Platform had challenged the rejection of its patent application, arguing that the Patent Office had examined the system and method claims together without separately assessing them. It submitted that withdrawing the method claim could affect the assessment of the system claim, which it continued to pursue.
The Patent Controller opposed the remand, contending that the rejection order provided detailed findings on each claim and considered Sections 3(k) and 3(m) of the Patents Act.
The Bench observed that withdrawing one claim while retaining the system claim could affect the Controller's conclusion on whether the patent deserved a grant. It relied on its earlier decisions in Optimedica Corporation v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, in which it had remitted patent applications for fresh consideration following amendments to the claims.
Accordingly, the High Court directed a different Patent Controller to reconsider the application afresh, restricting the examination to the system claim alone. It directed the Controller to decide the matter within four months of receiving the order.
It also permitted the Controller to seek the opinion of a scientific adviser, if necessary, from a professor at IIT Madras.
For Petitioner: Advocate Vineet Rohilla and R.Dayashariff for D.Subin
For Respondent: SCGSC V.Venkatesan