The Delhi High Court has held that the mere deployment of plant and machinery, technology and automation for cutting, slitting and processing steel coils cannot by itself justify treating a business as engaged in manufacturing activities for the purposes of transfer pricing benchmarking under the Income Tax Act, 1961.

The division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar observed that the classification of a business for transfer pricing purposes must be based on an examination of the actual functions performed, assets employed and risks assumed by the assessee.

“The mere deployment of plant and machinery, technology and automation for carrying out activities such as cutting, slitting and blanking of steel coils cannot, by itself, justify treating the Appellant as a manufacturer for the purposes of transfer pricing benchmarking,” the Court observed.

The Court was hearing an appeal filed by Rajasthan Prime Steel Processing Center Private Limited, a company associated with the Honda Group, challenging ITAT orders which upheld the segregation of its business into separate manufacturing and trading segments for transfer pricing assessment.

The company, which was engaged in trading and processing steel coils and supplying steel products to Honda Group companies, had adopted the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) for benchmarking its international transactions at the entity level for Assessment Year 2016–17.

However, the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) rejected this approach and divided the company's activities into separate manufacturing and trading segments, initially proposing an upward adjustment of ₹41.33 crore.

Following rectification proceedings and directions issued by the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), the adjustment was ultimately reduced to approximately ₹2.50 crore in the trading segment, while the adjustment concerning the manufacturing segment was deleted.

ITAT subsequently upheld the separate benchmarking of the two segments, prompting the company to approach the High Court.

Before the High Court, the company argued that it was essentially engaged in trading and value-added distribution of steel coils. It submitted that activities such as cutting, slitting and blanking involved limited processing without substantial value addition and could not automatically be characterised as manufacturing.

It further contended that the Income Tax Department had accepted its consolidated benchmarking approach for Assessment Years 2012–13, 2013–14 and 2014–15, despite there being no material change in its business activities.

Examining the matter, the High Court found that the DRP's findings regarding the nature of the company's operations were contradictory.

The Court noted that a substantial portion of the imported steel coils underwent only slitting, which did not attract central excise duty. A smaller portion was subjected to further manufacturing along with locally purchased materials.

It also referred to the earlier decision of the Delhi High Court in Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association v. Union of India, which recognised that cutting or slitting steel sheets does not amount to manufacture where no new and distinct article emerges from the process.

The Court observed that the company's business model had remained unchanged and that the Revenue had failed to demonstrate any change in circumstances warranting departure from the transfer pricing methodology accepted in earlier assessment years.

“The segregation of the Appellant's business into separate manufacturing and trading segments has not been supported by an adequate functional analysis,” the Court held.

It further found that ITAT had relied on entries in the company's profit and loss account, including excise duty, finished goods stock, fuel consumption and depreciation on machinery, without adequately verifying the underlying transactions.

It also noted that the Tribunal had failed to adjudicate material grounds concerning the principle of consistency and the allegedly arbitrary allocation of income and expenses between the two segments.

As such, the Court remanded the matter to the AO for fresh consideration and examine the company's transfer pricing study, the nature of its business activities, appropriate segmentation, selection of comparable companies and adjustments claimed, after granting an effective opportunity of hearing.

For Appellant: Advocates Nageswar Rao, Ravilochan Daliparthi, Pratik Rath, 

For Respndents: Advocates Ruchir Bhatia, SSC, Anant Mann, JSC, Pratyaksh Gupta JSC

Tags:    
Case Title :  Rajasthan Prime Steel Processing Center Pvt. Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr.Case Number :  ITA 175/2023CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1268