The Telangana High Court on 16 November dismissed the Income Tax Department's appeals against Eenadu Television, holding that expenditure on producing TV serials and programmes is deductible as revenue expenditure under Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
A Division Bench comprising Justices T. Vinod Kumar and Anil Kumar Jukanti also held that a film software library qualifies as an intangible asset eligible for depreciation at 25%. It observed:
“...It is to be noted that Section 32(5) of the Act would only stand attracted only when an asset is created, be it tangible or intangible but not otherwise. The production of a TV programme/serial cannot be considered as resulting in creation of an asset, tangible or intangible in nature for the assessee to utilize the said asset over a period of time to derive income, by utilizing the same like plant and machinery, software, copyright or patents, etc., for the expenditure incurred in relation to such asset to be considered as capital in nature…”
The dispute arose after the Assessing Officer treated the expenditure incurred by Eenadu Television on producing TV serials and programmes as capital expenditure and allowed depreciation under Section 32 instead of the deduction claimed as revenue expenditure. The Assessing Officer also disallowed depreciation claimed on the company's film software library.
For AY 2017-18, Eenadu Television had filed its return declaring a total income of Rs. 42.31 crore. Following scrutiny, the Assessing Officer determined its income at approximately Rs. 162.26 crore, including by treating the production costs as capital expenditure.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) allowed the company's claim, relying on the Tribunal's earlier decision in its own case and a decision concerning its sister concern, Prism TV Limited. The Tribunal subsequently upheld the allowance of production costs as revenue expenditure and held that the film software library qualified for depreciation at 25%.
Before the High Court, the Income Tax Department argued that expenditure on producing TV serials and programmes resulted in the creation of an asset carrying an enduring benefit because of its potential for repeat telecasts. It contended that the expenditure should therefore be capitalised and depreciated over the useful life of the programmes.
The Revenue submitted that the Delhi High Court's decision in Commissioner of Income Tax v. Television Eighteen India Ltd. was distinguishable as it concerned news content without repeat telecast value, unlike television serials and film rights. It also relied on Accounting Standard 26 to contend that the production costs resulted in the creation of intangible assets.
On the film software library, the department argued that the software was integral to the company's business operations and should be classified as plant and machinery, attracting depreciation at 15% instead of 25%.
Eenadu Television, on the other hand, submitted that its claim was under Section 37 of the Act and not under Rules 9A or 9B of the Income Tax Rules. It argued that the expenditure was incurred in the ordinary course of its business of producing and telecasting programmes and did not result in the creation of any capital asset.
The company also submitted that the Assessing Officer had not placed any material on record to establish that the programmes generated income through repeat telecasts or had a defined useful life warranting depreciation.
On the software issue, it contended that the film software library was an intangible asset specifically covered under Section 32(1)(ii) and was therefore eligible for depreciation at 25%.
The Court accepted the company's contentions. It relied on the Supreme Court's decisions in Empire Jute Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax and Alembic Chemical Works Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax. These decisions held that the test of enduring benefit was not conclusive in determining whether expenditure was capital or revenue in nature.
The Bench noted that the Revenue had not produced any material or evidence to establish that Eenadu Television had derived income from the alleged right of repeat telecast. It also took note of the company's specific submission that the production cost of an episode was expensed out once the serial was telecast.
Further, it held that the Revenue could not artificially create an asset and then allow depreciation on it under Section 32. It observed that producing a television programme or serial did not, by itself, result in the creation of a tangible or intangible asset capable of being utilised over a period of time to generate income.
It also rejected the Revenue's reliance on Accounting Standard 26, noting that no material had been placed on record to establish the life cycle or useful life of the television programmes for determining the period over which depreciation could be allowed.
Moreover, the judges relied on the Delhi High Court's decision holding that expenditure incurred on producing television programmes was revenue expenditure. The Bench rejected the Revenue's attempt to distinguish that ruling on the ground that it concerned news archives rather than television serials.
They also invoked the principle of consistency, noting that the Revenue had accepted the Tribunal's decision in the case of similarly placed taxpayer Prism TV Limited, which had allowed production costs as revenue expenditure.
Relying on the Supreme Court's decisions in CIT v. Narendra Doshi and Berger Paints India Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, the Bench held that the Revenue could not adopt a different approach in the case of another taxpayer on the same issue.
On the depreciation rate applicable to the film software library, it observed that the software was used to process a programme after its production. Unlike a television camera or other equipment without which shooting could not take place, the software was not indispensable for bringing a programme into existence and could not be classified as plant and machinery. It said:
“Insofar as the rate of depreciation on film software library is concerned, the film software library is a tool for processing of a program, after it is produced. Thus, it cannot be said that without the use of the software no program comes into existence like a TV camera or equipment, without which no shooting can take place, for software to be considered as Plant & Machinery.”
Applying the principle that a specific statutory entry prevails over a general description, the judges upheld the Tribunal's decision to allow depreciation at 25% by classifying the film software library as an intangible asset under Section 32(1)(ii) of the Act.
The Division Bench held that the production costs of television serials were allowable as revenue expenditure under Section 37 and found no error of law in the Tribunal's orders warranting interference under Section 260A of the Act.
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed both appeals filed by the Income Tax Department.
For the Revenue: Senior Standing Counsel.
For Eenadu Television: C.V. Narasimham.