The Delhi High Court has held that an assessee's earlier agreement to pay tax on alleged undisclosed foreign bank deposits, cannot sustain reassessment proceedings initiated through an invalid notice under Section 153A of the Income Tax Act.

The division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar observed that where the initiation of proceedings under Section 153A itself was legally unsustainable, all consequential proceedings would also stand vitiated, notwithstanding the assessee's earlier statement agreeing to pay tax.

"Viewed in this light, the fact that the Appellant had agreed to pay tax on the deposits in the said foreign account but had later on retracted from his statement after nine months also does not favour the Revenue because if the notice under Section 153A is bad, then all proceedings pursuant to the said notice also stand vitiated," the court held.

The observation came while allowing two income tax appeals filed by an assessee, challenging the addition of approximately ₹1.20 crore to his income in connection with an alleged undisclosed account maintained with HSBC Bank in Switzerland.

The dispute arose after Income Tax authorities conducted a search at Petitioner's residential premises during which he was shown documents allegedly indicating that he was the beneficial owner of a Swiss bank account.

Although Petitioner initially denied having any such account, he subsequently submitted a letter agreeing to pay tax on the deposits in the alleged foreign account.

However, he retracted the statement approximately nine months later.

The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) while upholding the addition, questioned the credibility of the retraction, observing that it had not been made at the earliest opportunity after the alleged pressure or coercion had ceased.

The authorities also relied on Petitioner's refusal to sign a consent waiver form that would have enabled the Department to obtain further details of the alleged bank account from Swiss authorities.

In the second round of proceedings, ITAT drew an adverse inference from the refusal to sign the waiver, observing that an innocent assessee would have no reason to fear verification of a nonexistent foreign account.

ITAT also considered his earlier agreement to pay tax as material supporting the Revenue's case.

However, before the High Court, Petitioner challenged the very jurisdiction of the authorities to proceed under Section 153A, arguing that no incriminating material concerning the alleged foreign bank account had been found during the search.

The High Court accepted this argument, noting that the seven-page document relating to the alleged HSBC account was already in the possession of the Revenue before the search was conducted.

The Court further noted that no incriminating material recovered during the search connected or corroborated those documents.

In this context, the Court rejected the Revenue's reliance on Petitioner's earlier agreement to pay tax and his subsequent retraction, holding that such circumstances could not cure the defect in the initiation of reassessment proceedings.

For Appellant: Advocates Satyen Sethi, Arta Trana Panda, Gargi Sethee, 

For Respondent: Advocates Shlok Chandra, SSC with Naincy Jain, JSC, Udit Dad and Ujjwal Jain

Tags:    
Case Title :  Parag Dalmia v. Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors.Case Number :  ITA 740/2018 and ITA 22/2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1262