The Rajasthan High Court has quashed income tax reassessment proceedings initiated solely on the basis of a Departmental Valuation Officer (DVO) report, holding that the Assessing Officer must demonstrate independent application of mind before reopening an assessment.

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal and Justice Sameer Jain observed:

"It is a settled principle of law that the mere existence of a valuation report cannot substitute the statutory requirement of formation of an independent belief by the Assessing Officer. The jurisdiction to reopen an assessment cannot be exercised mechanically or merely on the basis of an opinion furnished by another authority. The action of the respondent authority, therefore, cannot be sustained if the DVO report constituted the sole basis for initiation of reassessment proceedings and no independent material or application of mind was demonstrated in accordance with law."

The matter arose from petitions filed by Geeta Devi Jain and her family members challenging reassessment proceedings initiated against them for different assessment years.

The Income Tax Department had earlier added amounts to the petitioners' taxable income based on a DVO report estimating the cost of constructing a house. The appellate authority later deleted these additions, noting that the searches had not yielded any incriminating material.

The Department then reopened their assessments under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, relying on the same DVO report.

The petitioners argued that the DVO had used Central Public Works Department (CPWD) rates instead of State PWD rates. They said that using the latter would bring the alleged escaped income below ₹50 lakh, affecting the time limit for reopening assessments under Section 149.

Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in ACIT v. Dhariya Construction Co., the High Court held that a DVO report, by itself, cannot justify reopening an assessment. It also said the petitioners' objections over the construction rates needed proper consideration, as they had a bearing on the alleged escaped income and the Department's jurisdiction to reopen the assessments.

The Court rejected the Department's plea that the petitioners should pursue an alternative remedy, holding that writ jurisdiction could be invoked when the very assumption of jurisdiction was questioned.

It accordingly quashed the reassessment orders, notices and subsequent proceedings.

For Petitioners: Advocate Tanuj Agrawal 

For Respondents: Advocates Siddharth Bapna, Tanushka Saxena, Rahul Kumar, Jai Prakash Meena and Yashvi Khandelwal appeared for the respondents.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Geeta Devi Jain v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr. and connected mattersCase Number :  D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15442/2025 and connected petitionsCITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC(RAJ) 65