Business Expenses Can't Be Disallowed Solely Because No Revenue Was Earned During Year: Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court on Wednesday upheld the deletion of an ₹8.73 crore income tax disallowance against a real estate developer, observing that the allowability of business expenditure must be determined by its nature and purpose and not merely by the absence of project revenue during the assessment year.
The division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar dismissed an appeal filed by the Income Tax Department against an ITAT order allowing deductions claimed by Experion Developers for the assessment year 2012–13.
It observed,
"The allowability of expenditure has to be determined in accordance with the nature of the expenditure and whether it is attributable to the project or is otherwise incurred wholly and exclusively for the business."
The dispute arose after the Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed ₹8.73 crore, representing 90% of the ₹9.70 crore claimed by the company as revenue expenditure.
The AO reasoned that the expenditure was directly or indirectly connected with real estate projects under development and should have been capitalised as project cost or work-in-progress, particularly since no project revenue had been recognised during the relevant year.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the disallowance. However, the ITAT reversed the decision, finding that the company had allocated project-related expenses to inventory in accordance with the applicable accounting standards while claiming the remaining expenditure as business expenses.
The ITAT had observed that earning revenue was not a prerequisite for claiming deductions under Section 37 of the Income Tax Act, provided the business had been set up and the expenditure was incurred for business purposes.
It further found the AO's decision to allow 10% of the expenses while disallowing the remaining 90% on an ad hoc basis to be arbitrary.
Challenging the ITAT's order, the Income Tax Department argued before the High Court that expenses attributable to ongoing projects could not be claimed as revenue expenditure merely by describing them as such. It also questioned whether the company had sufficiently substantiated the classification of its expenses.
The Company meanwhile submitted that it had consistently followed the same accounting method and that neither the AO nor the appellate authority had identified any specific expenditure as incorrectly claimed.
The High Court noted that the ITAT had examined the accounting method followed by the company, the allocation of expenses to work-in-progress, the business purpose of the expenditure and the applicable accounting guidelines.
It held that the ITAT's findings were based on the material available on record and could not be termed perverse so as to warrant interference.
However, the Court clarified that the AO's partial allowance of expenditure could not, by itself, establish that the entire amount was deductible.
"It is indeed true that the partial allowance by the Assessing Officer cannot constitute a conclusive admission that the entire expenditure is deductible. The rule of consistency in the method of accounting cannot override the provisions of the IT Act," the Court observed.
Nevertheless, it noted that the ITAT had also relied on factual findings concerning the nature and allocation of the expenditure and dismissed the Department's appeal.
For Appellant: Advocates Vipul Agrawal, SSC along with Advocates Gaoraang Ranjan & Harshita Kotru
For Respondent: Advocates Rohit Jain & Vaibhav Kulkarni