ITAT Must Examine Validity Of TPO's Approach Before Upholding Transfer Pricing Adjustments: Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has held that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) must examine the validity of the approach adopted by the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) in determining the arm's length price of international transactions before proceeding to uphold transfer pricing adjustments.
The division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar made the observation while setting aside an ITAT order concerning transfer pricing adjustments made against Rajasthan Prime Steel Processing Centre Private Limited, a subsidiary of Japan-based Honda Trading Corporation, for assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11.
The court noted that the ITAT had failed to return a clear finding on the assessee's fundamental objection that the TPO had substituted its benchmarking analysis without expressly rejecting the transfer pricing study furnished by it.
“The ITAT, while noticing the rival submissions and the judicial precedents relied upon by the Assessee, has not returned a clear and categorical finding on this fundamental issue. In our view, the validity of the approach adopted by the TPO was required to be examined before proceeding to determine the correctness of the transfer pricing adjustments,” the court observed.
The dispute arose from international transactions entered into by the company with its associated enterprises, including the purchase of raw materials, payment of royalty and technical guidance fees, and purchase of capital goods.
During assessment proceedings, the TPO rejected the benchmarking approach adopted by the assessee, divided its business into manufacturing and trading segments, and independently applied the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM). This resulted in transfer pricing adjustments of approximately ₹14.91 crore for assessment year 2009-10 and ₹14.95 crore for assessment year 2010-11.
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) substantially upheld the TPO's approach while granting partial relief. Subsequently, the ITAT also upheld the segregation of the assessee's activities into manufacturing and trading segments and affirmed the application of TNMM, while directing reconsideration of certain comparables and adjustments.
Before the High Court, the assessee contended that the TPO had neither identified any specific deficiency in its transfer pricing study nor recorded valid reasons for disregarding it before undertaking an independent benchmarking exercise.
It was argued that the ITAT failed to adjudicate this objection despite the assessee relying on judicial precedents governing the rejection of transfer pricing studies.
The High Court noted that the ITAT had substantially relied on its earlier decision concerning the company's assessment year 2016-17 without independently examining the factual material and objections relevant to the assessment years under consideration.
Significantly, the High Court pointed out that the earlier ITAT decision for assessment year 2016-17 had itself been set aside by the High Court in a separate judgment dated November 5, 2026.
Since the impugned ITAT order substantially rested on findings that had subsequently been set aside, the Court held that the matter required fresh consideration.
As such, the Court remanded the matter to the AO for reconsideration.