An unsuccessful party in arbitration cannot secure interim protection after an adverse arbitral award merely by establishing a strong prima facie case. It must also demonstrate rare and compelling circumstances warranting such relief, the Delhi High Court has reiterated.
Justice Tushar Rao Gedela, relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Home Care Retail Marts Pvt. Ltd. v. Haresh N. Sanghavi and the Delhi High Court's decision in Thor Ventures (OPC) Private Limited v. Nyeq Technologies Private Limited, observed:
“Having said that, it is not every case where strong prima facie case as contemplated in Home Care Retail (supra) is made out, that the unsuccessful party is entitled to an interim protection orders under Section 9 of the Act, but only those which fall within the term 'rare and compelling case'.”
The court made the observation while refusing interim protection sought by former Driplex Water Engineering promoter Kimti Lall Jain over ₹38.91 crore deposited by third parties in proceedings relating to four project awards.
Jain and his family members were promoters of Driplex Water Engineering Private Limited and Driplex Water Engineering International Private Limited, which were acquired by Indian group companies of the Suez Group.
Under the transaction documents, certain outstanding payments from past contracts, described as Past Retention Money (PRM), were to be recovered and shared. A Supplementary Framework Agreement executed on March 1, 2019, provided a mechanism for Jain to pursue these recoveries. The agreement contemplated a 49-month recovery period, while the power of attorney issued to Jain expired on March 31, 2023, and was not renewed.
During this period, Jain secured favourable arbitral awards in five project disputes. In proceedings relating to four of those awards, BHEL, NTPC, NLC and MRPL deposited a total of ₹38.91 crore in court.
After disputes arose over the recovery of the PRM and the extension of his authority, Jain invoked arbitration on November 27, 2023. The tribunal rejected his claim for ₹156.46 crore towards PRM, along with two other claims, while partly allowing certain other claims. He challenged the rejection of his claims before the high court and separately sought interim protection over the deposits.
Jain argued that the deposits represented PRM recoveries attributable to his efforts. He also relied on the financial statements of the two companies to contend that their precarious financial position could jeopardise his ability to recover the amounts.
The court accepted that the four deposits constituted PRM and that the arbitral awards leading to them resulted from Jain's efforts. It also rejected the respondents' contention that the deposits were merely “top-up payments”, observing that they had not produced any contractual provision or document to substantiate this claim.
The court further found that the documents indicated that the two companies were in a precarious financial condition.
Accordingly, the court held that Jain had established a strong prima facie case, that the balance of convenience favoured him and that he was likely to suffer irreparable injury without interim protection.
However, the court found that these circumstances did not satisfy the additional requirement of a rare and compelling case. It observed that the arguments substantially concerned the merits of Jain's challenge to the arbitral award, while the efficacy of that challenge would not be diluted or compromised if the deposits were not preserved.
The court also noted that Jain had impleaded the holding companies of the two Driplex entities. If he succeeded in his challenge to the award, further proceedings or execution could still continue.
“Thus, while this Court holds that the petitioner is indeed entitled to an interim order, however, is unable to grant the same in view of the ratio in Home Care Retail Mart (supra) and Thor Ventures (supra) on the question of not meeting the standard of 'rare and compelling case',” the court observed.
It consequently rejected the interim prayer and listed the matter for further hearing on December 14, 2026, along with Jain's challenge to the arbitral award.
For Petitioner (Kimti Lall Jain): Senior Advocates Arvind Nigam and Nakul Dewan, with Advocates Manmeet Singh, Palak Nagar, Sadhvi Kumar and Namaan Shafi.
For Respondents 2–4 (Veolia Water Technologies and Solutions, Driplex Water Engineering Private Limited and Driplex Water Engineering International Private Limited): Senior Advocate Jayant Mehta, with Advocates Ganesh Chandru, Siddharth Agrawal, Shashwat Dhyani, Kesang T. Doma and Om Shelat.