The Madhya Pradesh High Court on 5 November held that a party does not waive its right to invoke arbitration merely because the contract designates it as the authority responsible for appointing the arbitrator or arbitral panel.

Justice Pradeep Mittal dismissed West Central Railway's appeal against the reference of its Rs. 3.98 lakh recovery claim against contractor R.K. Gupta to arbitration. The Bench

“A party does not waive their right to seek arbitration just because they are also the designated authority responsible for appointing the panel or arbitrator..."

West Central Railway entered into an agreement with Gupta on 20 December 2002 for tiling the platform surface at Timarani in Harda district. The Railways alleged that Gupta failed to complete the work within the stipulated time.

It issued a seven-day notice on 27 February 2003, followed by a 48-hour notice, and terminated the contract on 17 March 2003. The Railways then engaged Bhawani Construction, Bhopal, to complete the work and claimed an additional expenditure of Rs. 3,98,438.83.

The Railways sent Gupta a registered notice dated 6 May 2008, which he received on 10 May 2008. After receiving no response, it filed a recovery suit against him on 20 January 2009.

Gupta applied under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeking reference of the dispute to arbitration under Clauses 63 and 64 of the General Conditions of Contract.

On 12 August 2010, the trial court allowed the application and directed the return of the plaint.

The Railways initially challenged the order under Article 227 of the Constitution but withdrew the petition on 16 December 2011, with liberty to pursue an appeal. It subsequently filed an appeal under Order 43 Rule 1(a) of the Code of Civil Procedure on 29 January 2012.

It argued that Clause 64(1) authorised only Gupta to demand arbitration and that its claim for the additional cost of completing the work fell outside the arbitration clause.

The Court first held that Section 37 of the Arbitration Act did not provide a right of appeal against an order referring a dispute to arbitration under Section 8. The consequential direction to return the plaint also did not independently create a right of appeal under the Code of Civil Procedure.

On the merits, it noted that both parties accepted the existence of an arbitration agreement and that Gupta, whom the contract expressly authorised to demand arbitration, had himself sought reference of the dispute.

The Bench rejected the Railways' contention that the absence of an express contractual right to apply for arbitration meant that it had opted out of the arbitration mechanism. It observed:

“The argument that the principal "did not opt for arbitration" simply because the contract doesn't explicitly spell out their right to apply is weak and has no legal force.”

Further, Justice Mittal held that the claim for additional completion costs appeared to arise from the contractual rights and liabilities of the parties. The arbitration clause survived termination of the contract, and Gupta could dispute the amount claimed before the arbitral tribunal even though he had not challenged the termination itself.

Accordingly, the High Court affirmed the trial court's order without costs, leaving the parties free to contest the scope of the arbitration clause, contractual deadlines and the arbitrability of any excluded claims before the arbitral tribunal.

Appearances for petitioner (Union of India and Anr.): Advocate Rajesh Kumar Tiwari.

Appearances for respondent (R.K. Gupta): Advocate Deepak Kumaar Raghuwanshi.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Union of India and Anr. v. R.K. GuptaCase Number :  Miscellaneous Appeal No. 416 of 2012CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC(MP) 84