The Karnataka High Court has held that proceedings before the NCLT over allegations of fraud, mismanagement, and removal from directorship do not automatically bar arbitration of a separate contractual dispute arising from an employment agreement.

Justice H.T. Narendra Prasad observed that the two proceedings involved distinct legal rights and causes of action, even though they concerned the same parties and might involve overlapping facts.

“The mere existence of common factual circumstances does not necessarily render the causes of action identical. Nor does it follow that an independent contractual dispute becomes non-arbitrable merely because statutory proceedings concerning the affairs of the Company are pending before the NCLT.” the court held

Plutus Research Private Limited, a quantitative trading company, approached the High Court seeking appointment of a sole arbitrator to resolve disputes with its director and shareholder, Aashay Harlalka, arising from an Employment Agreement dated October 1, 2018.

The company alleged that Harlalka had breached his contractual obligations under the agreement and invoked the arbitration clause by issuing a notice dated April 7, 2025. As he did not respond or consent to the appointment of an arbitrator, the company approached the High Court.

Opposing the petition, Harlalka argued that the disputes involved allegations of fraud and mismanagement concerning the company's affairs, which were already the subject of proceedings before the NCLT, Ahmedabad. He also contended that the company had withdrawn an earlier application under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act before the NCLT without seeking liberty to initiate fresh proceedings and had suppressed the pendency of those proceedings.

The company argued that the NCLT proceedings concerned Harlalka's removal as a director, whereas the present dispute arose independently from alleged breaches of the Employment Agreement. It contended that withdrawal of the Section 8 application did not extinguish its right to seek arbitration under the agreement.

Rejecting Harlalka's contention that the disputes were non-arbitrable, the Court observed that the scope of enquiry under Section 11(6) is limited to examining the prima facie existence of a valid arbitration agreement. It said the Court need not examine the rival claims, defences or disputed facts in detail, as these are matters for the arbitral tribunal to decide.

It observed that the dispute arose from the alleged breach of the Employment Agreement. It said that whether Harlalka had breached his contractual obligations and whether the company was entitled to relief would require examination of evidence, which was beyond the Court's limited jurisdiction under Section 11(6) of the Act.

On the allegations of fraud and the pendency of criminal proceedings, the Court observed that their mere existence does not, by itself, render a dispute non-arbitrable. Distinguishing the nature of the two proceedings, the Bench noted:

“The proceedings before the NCLT concern the statutory rights and obligations arising under the Companies Act, 2013, whereas the dispute sought to be referred to arbitration concerns the contractual rights and obligations arising under the Employment Agreement.”

It further added, "Merely because the respondent happens to be a Director and Shareholder of the petitioner–Company, every dispute between the parties cannot be treated as a dispute relating to the management and affairs of the Company. The nature of the dispute must be determined with reference to the cause of action and the relief sought.”

The Court observed that the cause of action for invoking arbitration was the alleged breach of Clauses 11 to 15 of the Employment Agreement, making the dispute prima facie contractual in nature.

"The mere fact that proceedings concerning the affairs of the Company are pending before the NCLT does not automatically deprive the Arbitral Tribunal of jurisdiction to adjudicate an independent contractual dispute.” it held

On whether the withdrawal of the Section 8 application before the NCLT barred the present petition, the Court clarified that Section 8 provides for referring a dispute to arbitration when proceedings are brought before a judicial authority, while Section 11 provides for the appointment of an arbitrator.

“25. The two provisions operate in different spheres, although both seek to give effect to the agreement between the parties to resolve their disputes through arbitration.” it noted

It further noted that Section 8(3) expressly permits arbitration to commence or continue, and an arbitral award to be passed, despite the pendency of a Section 8 application. The Bench therefore held that the mere pendency of such an application does not bar proceedings under Section 11 of the Act.

The Court also held that there was no material to prima facie establish that the company had relinquished its right to invoke the arbitration clause under the Employment Agreement. Therefore, withdrawal of the Section 8 application did not, by itself, render the present petition not maintainable.

On the allegation of suppression of proceedings, the Court observed that while a party seeking discretionary relief must approach the Court with clean hands and disclose all material facts, every omission or non-disclosure does not necessarily warrant dismissal of the proceedings.

Rejecting Harlalka's argument against bifurcation, the Court held that the NCLT proceedings concerned the company's affairs and management, while the arbitration proceedings involved alleged breaches of the Employment Agreement. It observed that despite involving the same parties and some overlapping facts, the two proceedings arose from distinct legal rights and causes of action.

Accordingly, the Court allowed the petition and appointed Justice V Jagannathan, Former Judge, Karnataka High Court as the Sole Arbitrator.

For Petitioner: Advocates Ananya Ghosh and Arjun Rao

For Respondent: Advocate Suraj S

Tags:    
Case Title :  Plutus Research Private Limited v. Aashay HarlalkaCase Number :  Civil Misc. Petition No. 503 of 2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 237