The Delhi High Court on 3 November held that an arbitral tribunal's failure to separately consider a contractual provision does not, by itself, constitute patent illegality warranting interference under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The omission must go to the root of the award and materially affect its decision.

Justice Om Prakash Shukla dismissed a petition filed by Winner Construction Pvt. Ltd. challenging an arbitral award that rejected its claims for interest on delayed payment of the final bill, cost escalation of labour and materials, and additional establishment expenses arising from a construction contract with the Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee (APMC). The Bench observed:

“In view of the finding that the final running bill had been prepared by the Engineer-in-Charge upon the Petitioner's failure to submit it, the omission to separately discuss Clause 9 does not materially affect the basis of the decision. The omission, therefore, cannot be said to constitute an error going to the root of the impugned Award or render the finding perverse or patently illegal so as to warrant interference under Section 34 of the Act.”

APMC awarded the construction contract to Winner Construction in October 2004 for a new office building at the National Farmers Market (NFM), Azadpur, Delhi. The work was scheduled for completion by November 2005 but was completed in November 2006. APMC granted extensions of time without imposing compensation for the delay.

Subsequently, Winner Construction invoked arbitration and sought Rs. 1,75,52,560 towards various claims, including interest on delayed payment of the final bill and prolongation expenses. The arbitrator partly allowed the claims but rejected those relating to interest and prolongation expenses.

Challenging the award, Winner Construction argued that the arbitrator relied on Clause 7 of the General Conditions of Contract (GCC) to reject its claim for interest on delayed payment of the final bill but failed to consider Clause 9. It contended that Clause 9 required payment of the final bill within six months of its receipt.

The High Court referred to Supreme Advertising Private Limited v. Genus Power Infrastructures Limited, which held that assessing evidence and determining the weight to be attached to it ordinarily fall within the arbitral tribunal's domain.

It clarified that the question was whether the omission to consider particular documents undermined the reasoning or conclusion of the award, and not merely whether the tribunal had separately mentioned each document.

Examining Clauses 7 and 9, the Bench noted that Clause 9 required the contractor to submit the final bill, whereas Clause 7 prescribed the procedure to be followed if the contractor failed to do so, including preparation of the bill by the Engineer-in-Charge.

The arbitrator had found that Winner Construction had not submitted the final running bill and that APMC's Engineer-in-Charge had prepared it. The Court observed that the parties' subsequent joint signing of the bill could indicate their acceptance of the recorded measurements or the amount stated in it.

However, the Bench noted that this did not establish that Winner Construction had initially submitted the bill in the manner contemplated under Clause 9. The contractor had also failed to identify any material demonstrating that the finding regarding preparation of the bill by APMC was perverse or unreasonable.

Further, it relied on National Highways Authority of India v. GVK Jaipur Expressway Pvt. Ltd., 2023 SCC OnLine Del 3790, and reiterated:

“…the non-consideration of a contractual provision does not, by itself, constitute patent illegality unless such omission goes to the root of the Award…”

Moreover, the Court rejected Winner Construction's reliance on internal notes indicating that the payment delay resulted from budgetary or administrative reasons.

On the claims for escalation and additional establishment expenses, it held that Winner Construction had failed to establish that APMC caused the delay. It observed that the existence of site hindrances, by itself, was insufficient to presume that the employer was responsible for them.

Justice Shukla observed that pre-reference interest cannot be awarded as a matter of course and must be supported by a contractual provision or another substantive legal basis. He also relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Ramesh Kumar Jain v. Bharat Aluminium Company Limited (BALCO), 2025 INSC 1457, which emphasised that courts must apply the test of patent illegality with caution.

Accordingly, the High Court found that the arbitrator's conclusions were supported by the evidence and dismissed the petition.

For the Petitioner: Advocates Anusuya Salwan, Nikita Salwan and Rachit Wadhwa.

For the Respondent: Advocates C.S. Parasher, Ashish and Mona Sharma, along with Assistant Engineer Kamal Kumar

Tags:    
Case Title :  M/s Winner Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Agricultural Produce Marketing CommitteeCase Number :  O.M.P. (COMM) 13/2015CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1252