Madras High Court Sets Aside Sundaram Finance Auction Of Joint Property Over Children's One-Third Share
The Madras High Court on 12 November allowed an appeal filed by S.N.R. Richlin Vivegha and S.N.R. Julian Joshua, children of borrower S.N.R. Joshva Rathinaraj, against the attachment and court auction sale of their inherited share in a jointly owned property to recover dues owed to Sundaram Finance.
Justice P Murugan held that property jointly owned by a borrower and his deceased wife cannot be attached and sold in execution of an arbitral award without excluding the undivided share inherited by their children, who were not parties to the loan agreement. The Bench observed:
“The first item of properties belongs not only to the first respondent and also the petitioners' mother, who was not signatory to any agreement with the second respondent. Therefore, her share of the property cannot be attached without hearing the said person or her legal heirs.”
The dispute arose from Sundaram Finance's efforts to recover an arbitral award against S.N.R. Joshva Rathinaraj and Vathsalabai Poly Anne, who had borrowed from the company.
An arbitral award was passed on 12 November 2009, following which Sundaram Finance initiated execution proceedings in 2011. However, the property in question belonged jointly to Rathinaraj and his wife, Mercy Sweetylin. They had purchased it through a registered sale deed dated 4 December 2002, for Rs. 8.96 lakh.
Sweetylin, who was neither a borrower nor a party to the arbitral award, died in a road accident on 20 June 2005. Her half-share devolved upon Rathinaraj and their children, S.N.R. Richlin Vivegha and minor S.N.R. Julian Joshua.
Consequently, the children jointly inherited a one-third share in the property, while Rathinaraj owned the remaining two-thirds. Neither Sundaram Finance nor the auction purchaser, John Alexander, disputed their respective shares.
Despite this, the executing court attached the entire property on 11 August 2011 and subsequently sold it through a court auction to Alexander for Rs. 36.02 lakh. The children challenged the sale through an application filed on 6 September 2019.
After the Principal District Court, Thoothukudi, dismissed their application on 19 July 2024, they approached the High Court under Section 104 read with Order XLIII Rule 1(j) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
The children contended that the executing court had overlooked the joint ownership recorded in the sale deed and wrongly subjected their inherited share to recovery of their father's liability.
Sundaram Finance opposed the challenge, arguing that the application exceeded the 60-day limitation period prescribed under Article 127 of the Limitation Act, 1963. It also alleged collusion between the children and Rathinaraj. Alexander maintained that he was a bona fide auction purchaser who had deposited the purchase money.
The Court found that the executing court had mechanically attached the entire property without examining the ownership records. It observed that attaching the entire property without excluding the children's one-third share was “not only irregularity and also a patent error”.
On limitation, the Bench noted that both children were minors when the property was attached. Vivegha challenged the sale within three years of attaining majority, while Julian Joshua was still a minor when the application was filed.
Applying Article 60 read with Article 137 of the Limitation Act, it held that the application was within the limitation period.
Accordingly, the High Court set aside the dismissal order and the sale confirmation recorded on 8 February 2019. It restored the execution petition and directed Sundaram Finance to amend its prayer and property schedule to proceed only against Rathinaraj's two-thirds share, excluding the children's undivided one-third share. Any further attachment and sale must follow due process.
No costs were awarded.
Appearances for respondent (Sundaram Finance Ltd.): Advocates S. Pon Senthil Kumaran.
Appearances for respondent (John Alexander): Advocates V. Malaiyendran.