The Delhi High Court has recently held that a State government authority cannot escape the Centre's Vivad Se Vishwas II (Contractual Disputes) scheme, an amnesty scheme, merely because it is not a Central government entity if it routes a contract through a Central Public Sector Enterprise.

The court ruled that the State authority must fund the settlement even though the procurement was undertaken through a Central government entity.

"Once a procurement is done by any public authority (which may not be an instrumentality of the Central Government) through a Central Public Sector Enterprise as enumerated in paragraph 4 of the Scheme, then the scheme in effect is made applicable to such public authority," Justice Amit Mahajan ruled.

The Court also held that the pendency of a challenge to an arbitral award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, does not prevent settlement under the scheme.

"Even the pendency of a challenge under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 cannot act as an embargo for the implementation of the scheme as paragraph 10(b) of the Scheme specifically provides that the case may or may not be under challenge/appeal before a Court," the Court observed.

The dispute arose from a contract awarded to Maytas Subhash for construction of road works on the Noida–Greater Noida Expressway. IRCON International Limited had awarded the contract on behalf of the Noida Authority.

An arbitral award dated June 6, 2016, directed IRCON to pay Maytas Subhash ₹9.44 crore with 12% annual interest from the date of the award until payment. The arbitrator also rejected IRCON's counterclaims.

The Ministry of Finance introduced the Vivad Se Vishwas II scheme on May 29, 2023, as a one-time settlement mechanism for pending contractual disputes. Maytas Subhash subsequently submitted a settlement claim of ₹8.21 crore, representing 65% of the net amount payable under the award.

IRCON rejected the proposal on August 23, 2024, stating that it could not accept the settlement without the Noida Authority's permission. It argued that the Authority, being responsible for funding the settlement, had to approve the proposal.

Challenging the rejection, Maytas Subhash argued that IRCON, as a Central Public Sector Enterprise and the procuring entity, was competent to accept the settlement. It contended that Paragraph 22 of the scheme did not give the Noida Authority any veto over that decision.

The Noida Authority argued that the scheme applied only to specified Central government entities and did not cover it as an instrumentality of the Uttar Pradesh government.

Rejecting the objections, the Court held that Paragraph 22 of the scheme assigned separate responsibilities to the procuring entity and the public authority. IRCON was the competent authority to accept the settlement, while the Noida Authority was required to provide the funds.

The Court noted that Paragraph 22(i) used mandatory language. It did not require the procuring entity to obtain the public authority's consent before accepting a settlement.

"The mandatory language thus employed in paragraph 22(i) leaves no room for doubt that the procuring entity would be the competent authority to accept settlement, and it cannot abdicate the obligation entrusted to it under paragraph 22(i) by referring the ultimate decision to Respondent No. 2," the Court held.

It further pointed out that Paragraph 18 required procuring entities to accept eligible settlement claims of ₹500 crore or less. Maytas Subhash's claim fell within this limit.

The court also rejected the Noida Authority's argument that the scheme was inapplicable because it was a State government entity. It observed that Paragraph 22 did not restrict the expression "public authority" to Central government departments or organisations.

Having chosen to route the procurement through IRCON, a Central Public Sector Enterprise covered by the scheme, the Noida Authority could not subsequently disassociate itself from the settlement framework governing the contract.

The court also found that the arbitral award met the scheme's eligibility conditions. It involved monetary relief, arose from domestic arbitration and was passed before the January 31, 2023 cut-off date.

Allowing the petition on November 5, 2026, the Court set aside IRCON's rejection of the settlement claim and directed it to execute the settlement under the scheme. The Noida Authority was required to provide the funds.

For Petitioner (Maytas Subhash): Advocates Kirtiman Singh, Senior Advocate, Siddhant Jaiswal, Ritwik.

For Respondent (Noida Authority): Advocate Abhay Kr. Tayal.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Maytas Subhash v. IRCON International Limited & Anr.Case Number :  W.P.(C) 15607/2024CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1244