The Delhi High Court on 27 October issued notice on whether an arbitrator can impose costs payable to the arbitral tribunal itself, while staying the payment of Rs. 50,000 and Rs. 70,000 imposed on two parties for delayed defence filings.
Justice Ajay Digpaul passed the interim order on petitions filed by Shankar Enterprises and Jagdish Enterprises challenging the costs imposed in their respective arbitrations with Bihani Manufacturing Private Limited. The Bench observed:
“Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, it is prima facie observed that the aspect of imposition of costs upon the petitioners, which are required to be deposited before the learned Arbitral Tribunal vide impugned orders dated 03.10.2026, and 09.10.2026, warrants consideration by this Court.”
Bihani Manufacturing had initiated separate arbitration proceedings against Shankar Enterprises and another, and Jagdish Enterprises and another. In the proceedings, the arbitrator had closed the defending parties' right to file their statements of defence through orders dated 24 August and 29 August 2026.
Subsequently, the parties filed applications under Sections 18 and 19 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, seeking recall or modification of those orders to restore their opportunity to file the defence statements.
They also filed separate applications seeking condonation of a six-day delay in transmitting or filing the defence statements under Sections 43, 18 and 19 of the Arbitration Act, read with Section 151 CPC.
Through orders dated 3 October and 9 October 2026, the arbitrator allowed the applications seeking restoration of the opportunity to file the defence statements, subject to costs of Rs. 25,000 and Rs. 35,000, respectively, payable to the tribunal.
The Tribunal directed the parties to file their defence statements within one week, failing which their right to file them would stand closed. It also allowed the delay-condonation applications, imposing additional costs of Rs. 25,000 and Rs. 35,000, respectively.
Although the parties had not explained the delay, the arbitrator considered condonation appropriate in the interests of justice and equality. Further, it directed the parties to deposit the respective amounts with the tribunal within three weeks.
Challenging these directions, Shankar Enterprises and Jagdish Enterprises argued that Section 31A of the Arbitration Act does not empower an arbitral tribunal to impose costs payable to itself. They contended that the provision permits an arbitrator to determine whether costs are payable by one party to another and the manner in which they must be paid.
Relying on the Bombay High Court's decision in Modi Dairy v. Alfa Laval (India) Ltd., they argued that an arbitrator, apart from charging fees, cannot impose costs payable to the arbitrator for delayed pleadings or for seeking extensions.
Finding that the challenge warranted consideration, the High Court stayed the orders dated 3 October and 9 October to the extent that they required the petitioners to deposit costs with the tribunal, until the next hearing.
It clarified that “the proceedings pending before the learned Arbitral Tribunal shall proceed further in accordance with law," and issued notice, which advocate Nabab Singh accepted on behalf of Bihani Manufacturing.
Accordingly, the High Court stayed the payment of costs to the arbitral tribunal without finally deciding the issue.
The case is listed again for 25 November 2026.
Appearances for petitioner (Shankar Enterprises & Anr.; Jagdish Enterprises & Anr.): Advocates Nikhil Rajput.
Appearances for respondent (Bihani Manufacturing Private Limited): Advocates Nabab Singh.