Delhi HC Allows Vacancy Allowance For Properties Previously Rented Out Despite Genuine Efforts To Find Tenants
The Delhi High Court has held that properties previously let out on rent but remaining vacant during the relevant assessment year despite genuine efforts to find tenants can qualify for vacancy allowance under Section 23(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
The division bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar upheld the deletion of an addition of ₹3.28 crore made by the Income Tax Department against real estate developer DLF Ltd. towards notional rental income from vacant commercial properties.
The Court observed that the four commercial units in question had been let out in previous years but remained vacant during Assessment Year 2007-08 despite the company's genuine efforts to find suitable tenants.
"The present case shows that the 4 properties were in fact were let out in the previous years, however, despite making genuine efforts, the Assessee/Respondent could not find the suitable tenant for the 4 vacant properties in the relevant assessment year and therefore, Section 23(1)(c) of the Act will squarely cover the case in favor of the Respondent/Assessee," the Court observed.
The case arose from an appeal filed by the Income Tax Department challenging an ITAT order which had upheld the deletion of various tax additions made against DLF for Assessment Year 2007-08.
Of the 23 units situated in three commercial properties belonging to DLF, 19 had been let out while four remained vacant during the relevant assessment year.
The Assessing Officer had made additions towards annual letting value, including notional rent on the vacant units. However, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) deleted the additions after noting that the company intended to let out the vacant properties but could not find suitable tenants. The ITAT subsequently upheld the decision.
Before the High Court, the Revenue argued that vacant or unsold properties were liable to be assessed for notional rental income under Sections 22 and 23 of the Income Tax Act.
It relied on the Delhi High Court's earlier decision in Ansal Housing & Constructions Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, where the Court had declined vacancy allowance in respect of properties that had not previously been let out.
DLF however submitted that its four vacant commercial units had been rented out in earlier years and that it had produced documents demonstrating its efforts to secure tenants during the relevant assessment year.
The Court referred to the Andhra Pradesh High Court's decision in Vivek Jain v. CIT concerning the interpretation of Section 23(1)(c), and expressed agreement with the view taken therein.
Applying the provision to DLF's case, it held that the company's previous rental history and genuine efforts to find tenants entitled it to the benefit of vacancy allowance.
The Court also distinguished the decision in Ansal Housing, observing that the properties involved in that case had never been let out in previous years, whereas DLF's four commercial units had previously been rented.
It further noted that the ITAT was the final authority on factual findings and that the High Court could interfere under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act only where a substantial question of law arose or the decision was perverse or manifestly illegal.
As such, the Court dismissed the Revenue's appeal.
For Appellant: Advocates Sunil Agarwal SSC, Ms Monica Benjamin JSc, Gibran Naushad JSc, Adeeb Ahmed ,Harshita Sharma
For Respondent: Senior Advocate Kavita Jha,with Advocates Aditeya Bali, Akash Shukla