Creditor Cannot Pursue Parallel Challenge To Undervalued Transaction Already Examined By RP: NCLT Indore
The Indore Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has ruled that a creditor cannot use the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) to reopen an alleged undervalued transaction already examined by the Resolution Professional (RP), where the Liquidator has also initiated proceedings in relation to it.
A coram of Judicial Member Brajendra Mani Tripathi and Technical Member Man Mohan Gupta observed:
“Section 47 provides a remedy to a creditor where the liquidator or the resolution professional has not brought an undervalued transaction before this Tribunal. It is not a provision under which a creditor can reopen the view that the liquidator or the resolution professional has formed on examining the transaction, or carry on a proceeding parallel to the one he has been allowed to take.”
The tribunal was hearing an application filed by operational creditor Munnalal Pannalal Constructions Private Limited, challenging the sale of SRK Devbuild Private Limited's land and school building to Aegis Educational Society for ₹14.35 crore through a sale deed dated January 2, 2019.
The creditor alleged that the sale was undervalued and that the entire consideration had not been paid, although the sale deed recorded full payment. It also claimed that Aegis was a related party of the corporate debtor and sought to have the transaction declared void under Sections 45, 47, and 49 of the IBC.
The creditor argued that the RP had failed to approach the tribunal despite requests to examine the sale, allowing it to invoke Section 47. The Liquidator countered that the transaction had already been examined and independently valued at ₹14.40 crore, close to the ₹14.35 crore sale price. He also initiated proceedings to recover ₹1.37 crore in unpaid consideration. The NCLT held that the creditor could not use Section 47 to reopen the examination or pursue a parallel proceeding.
The tribunal further observed that undervaluation was not established on the material before it. However, it clarified that it had not decided whether the valuation report was correct.
The NCLT did not decide whether Aegis was a related party or whether the sale was undervalued. It directed the Liquidator to place the related-party allegation before the SCC at its next meeting for consideration.
Dismissing the application as not maintainable, the tribunal clarified that the creditor's rights and remedies, including its objections to the valuation report, were preserved before the competent court.
For Applicants: Pratik Tripathi, PCS
For Respondents: Advocates Vijay Assudani, Jayesh Sitlani and Soumya Dharwa