The Ahmedabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has held that secured creditors cannot use subsequent No Objection Certificates (NOCs) to exclude arbitration receivables from a concluded going-concern sale when the Sale Certificate does not provide for such an exclusion.
A Bench of Judicial Member Shammi Khan and Technical Member Sanjeev Sharma allowed an application filed by Rakesh Ramanlal Shah and Electrify Energy Pvt. Ltd. and directed State Bank of India, Indian Bank, IDBI Bank and Karnataka Bank to issue revised NOCs without excluding the arbitration receivables, while preserving the rights of STCI Finance Limited in pending proceedings before the Supreme Court. It held:
“To the extent the validity and implementation of the sale as a going concern have been upheld in the appellate proceedings, the terms of the Sale Certificate cannot be enlarged or varied by a subsequent NOC issued by an individual creditor. A subsequent NOC cannot, by itself, introduce an exclusion which is absent from the concluded terms of sale.”
The dispute arose from the liquidation of IMP Powers Limited, whose assets were sold as a going concern through an e-auction conducted on 21 May 2024. Rakesh Ramanlal Shah, in consortium with Electrify Energy Pvt. Ltd., emerged as the successful bidder with an offer of Rs. 78 crore.
After the applicants paid the entire consideration, the Liquidator issued a Sale Certificate on 21 August 2024. The applicants contended that the sale covered the corporate debtor as a going concern, including all its assets and liabilities except cash and bank balances. They maintained that the sale documents did not provide for any exclusion of arbitration receivables.
STCI Finance Limited had earlier challenged the liquidation process. However, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) and subsequently the Supreme Court declined to interfere with the validity of the going-concern sale.
The applicants submitted that despite the sale attaining finality, certain financial creditors subsequently incorporated a condition titled “Absolute Exclusion of Arbitration Receivables” in their NOCs.
They also relied on an earlier NCLT order dated 5 November 2024, which provided that the corporate debtor's existing and future receivables and claims, refunds, credits, benefits, rights and entitlements would continue to vest in the corporate debtor and/or the successful auction purchaser.
Examining the Sale Certificate, the Tribunal noted that the corporate debtor had been sold as a going concern, excluding cash and bank balances. It further noted that the appellate proceedings had upheld the validity and implementation of the sale as a going concern.
It held that individual creditors could not enlarge, vary or rewrite the terms of a concluded sale by subsequently incorporating additional conditions in their NOCs.
Finding no ambiguity in the Sale Certificate, the Bench held that Respondents 2 to 5 could not exclude arbitration receivables, claims or future realisations through their NOCs when the concluded sale terms contained no such exclusion.
Accordingly, the NCLT directed the four lenders to issue revised NOCs within seven days.
For Applicants: Advocate Munjal Bhatt