The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Kolkata, on 6 November dismissed an insolvency petition against Jharkhand Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (JBVNL), holding that a claim arising from an arbitral award cannot be enforced through insolvency proceedings after the expiry of the limitation period for executing the award.
A Bench of Judicial Member Labh Singh and Technical Member Rekha Kantilal Shah dismissed a petition filed under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) by Anvil Investments Private Limited, observing that a mere challenge to an arbitral award does not suspend the limitation period for its execution. It said:
“It is undisputed fact that there is no stay on the execution of the award dated 02.02.2013. Therefore, in the absence of any order staying recovery or execution, a mere challenge to an award does not stop running the period of limitation. Furthermore, the Operational Creditor has failed to establish any written acknowledgment of liability executed by the Corporate Debtor under Section 18 of the Limitation Act within the prescribed period of three years.”
Anvil Investments had approached the NCLT alleging that JBVNL failed to clear dues towards the supply of ACSR conductors and G.I. wires under eight purchase orders issued between 2001 and 2003.
The dispute was referred to the Jharkhand Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council, which passed an arbitral award in February 2013. Anvil Investments claimed that the award amount, along with interest, had accumulated to Rs. 8,39,88,802.76 as of April 2023.
JBVNL opposed the petition, contending that the claim was barred by limitation under Section 238A of the IBC, read with Article 137 of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963.
The Tribunal noted that Anvil Investments had served a copy of the award on JBVNL through a letter dated 11 March 2013, demanding payment. However, it failed to take steps to execute the award despite the absence of any order staying its execution.
It observed that Section 238A of the IBC, read with Article 137 of the Limitation Act, prescribes a three-year limitation period for filing applications under Sections 7, 9 and 10 of the IBC. The limitation period begins to run from the date of default. It observed:
“…as per provision of Section 238A read with Article 137 of the Limitation Act 1963, the period of limitation is three years for filing application under Section 7 or 9 or 10 of the IBC Code. The period of limitation starts running from the date of default. Therefore, the petition has to be filed within a period of three years from the date of default after excluding the period permissible at law.”
Further, the Bench noted that Anvil Investments issued the demand for payment on 11 March 2013. Therefore, the three-year limitation period expired in March 2016. The Bench also clarified that an operational debt under Section 5(21) of the IBC must be legally recoverable and cannot constitute a time-barred claim.
Accordingly, the NCLT dismissed the Section 9 petition as barred by limitation.
For Applicant: Mr. Joy Saha, Ld. Sr. Advocate, Mr. Ishaan Saha, Ld. Advocate, Mr. Debayan Ghosh, Ld. Advocate and Mr. Satyam Bhimsaria, Ld. Advocate
For Respondent: Mr. Sachin Kumar, Ld. Advocate, Mr. Surendra kumar, Ld. Advocate, and Mr. Akash Sharma, Ld. Advocate