The New Delhi Bench of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), on 29 October held that although a Committee of Creditors (CoC) may relax eligibility conditions for an MSME promoter, it cannot be compelled to do so merely because the corporate debtor enjoys MSME status.
A Bench comprising Judicial Member Justice Mohd Faiz Alam Khan and Technical Member Naresh Salecha dismissed an appeal filed by Shobhit J. Rajan, promoter and suspended director of Ecstasy Realty Private Limited, challenging the rejection of his Expression of Interest (EOI) in the company's Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP). It observed:
“We make it clear that we are not holding that a CoC can never relax the net worth criterion for an MSME promoter. A CoC may do so, if it thinks fit in the interest of a better resolution. All we hold is that no tribunal can compel it to do so on the basis of MSME status.”
The Corporate Debtor, a real estate company registered as a Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise (MSME), was admitted into CIRP on 9 March 2026. Following the invitation for expressions of interest, the CoC approved eligibility criteria requiring prospective resolution applicants to have a minimum standalone net worth of Rs. 400 crore or an equivalent tangible net worth at the consortium level.
Rajan submitted his EOI within the stipulated timeline and deposited Rs. 5 crore as earnest money. However, he did not furnish the mandatory net-worth certificate and instead marked the requirement as “not applicable”, claiming that Section 240A of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) protected him as the promoter of an MSME.
After giving him an opportunity to cure the deficiency, the Resolution Professional (RP) rejected his EOI on 22 June 2026 for failure to comply with the eligibility requirements. Rajan challenged the rejection before the Mumbai Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), which dismissed his application, leading to the present appeal.
Rajan argued that Section 240A was enacted to facilitate the participation of MSME promoters in the resolution process and that the net-worth criterion should not have been mechanically applied to him.
He submitted that the RP failed to consider his timely EOI, the Rs. 5 crore earnest money deposit, his income-tax returns, CIBIL score and willingness to disclose his sources of funding. He also contended that the RP should have placed his EOI before the CoC for evaluation instead of rejecting it at the threshold.
Moreover, he argued that treating an MSME promoter identically to an outsider for every procedural requirement would defeat the legislative objective of facilitating the revival of MSMEs. According to him, the RP could have considered alternative safeguards.
The RP and the sole-member CoC opposed the appeal, arguing that Section 240A exempts MSME resolution applicants only from the disqualifications under Sections 29A(c) and 29A(h) of the IBC. It does not exempt them from eligibility conditions prescribed under Section 25(2)(h).
They submitted that the CoC had approved the Rs. 400 crore net-worth threshold after considering the scale and value of the Corporate Debtor's real estate project. They also pointed out that the criterion applied uniformly to all prospective resolution applicants and that the CoC had not granted any relaxation.
The Appellate Tribunal noted that Sections 29A and 25(2)(h) operate in distinct fields. While Section 29A prescribes disqualifications for resolution applicants, Section 25(2)(h) empowers the RP, with the CoC's approval, to prescribe positive eligibility criteria having regard to the scale and complexity of the corporate debtor's business.
It observed that Section 240A specifically relaxes the application of Sections 29A(c) and 29A(h) to resolution applicants participating in the CIRP of an MSME. Section 240A(2) also empowers the Central Government to notify, in the public interest, that any provision of the Code will not apply to MSMEs. However, no such notification had been issued in the present case.
Further, the Bench held that neither the NCLT nor the NCLAT could expand the statutory exemption beyond what Parliament had expressly provided. Consequently, an MSME promoter who otherwise satisfies the requirements of Section 29A must still comply with the eligibility conditions applicable to all prospective resolution applicants.
It also rejected the argument that exceptional circumstances warranted relaxation of the net-worth criterion. It observed that MSME status and promoter status were common features of such cases and could not, by themselves, constitute exceptional circumstances.
The Tribunal also found that the appellant's income-tax returns, credit score and earnest money deposit could not substitute the prescribed net-worth criterion. It also noted that he had not attempted to establish that he actually possessed the required net worth.
Considering the admitted valuation of the Corporate Debtor's assets and the scale of its project, it held that the CoC was justified in insisting on financial capability from prospective resolution applicants. It emphasised that such commercial decisions fell within the CoC's domain.
The appellant had also argued that the net-worth requirement could have been satisfied through alternative forms of financial assurance. Rejecting this contention, the Bench observed:
“This was a matter for the CoC. It chose the net worth certificate as the test, because it is an independent and verifiable document. A tribunal cannot replace it with another test of its own choosing. The CoC is not barred from accepting other forms of comfort, but it is not bound to.”
Accordingly, finding no infirmity in the NCLT's order, the NCLAT dismissed the appeal.
For Appellants: Senior Advocate Abhinav Vasisht, with Advocates Aman Kacheria, Pulkit Sharma, Rishabh Dhanuka, Akshita S. Jaitly, Abhilasha Sharma, Zaki Ansari, Khushi Nandu, Jasleen, Shivanshu
For Respondents: Senior Advocate Krishnendu Datta with Advocates. Misha, Soummo Biswas, Mahima Sareen, Yugal Jain, Ritika Sharma, Gayathri Balasubramanian, Nandini Kaushik for R1; Advocates Bishwajit Dubey, Kaustubh Rai, Akshit Awasthi, Aayush Dogra for R2