The Supreme Court has laid down five guidelines for the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) to follow when remanding an approved resolution plan to the Committee of Creditors (CoC).

The court said that such remand must be in furtherance of the objectives of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, rest on a finding of legal noncompliance under Section 30(2) or any other law within the meaning of Section 61(3)(i) of the Code, and be exercised sparingly and within strict timelines.

A bench of Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Alok Aradhe issued the guidelines while dismissing appeals filed by Twinstar Technologies Limited, the successful resolution applicant in the insolvency proceedings concerning Videocon Industries Limited and 12 other group companies

A division bench of Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Alok Aradhe issued the following guidelines:

a) The power of remand is to be exercised only in furtherance of the objectives of the Code, namely, keeping the corporate debtor a going concern, ensuring a fair and reasonable recovery for all classes of creditors, and maximising the value of the corporate debtor's assets during the CIRP. A remand that advances none of these objectives is not justified merely because the power to order it exists.

b) Remand must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance, whether under Section 30(2) or under any other law within the meaning of Section 61(3)(i). This follows from the confined grounds on which an appeal against an approved resolution plan lies.

c) Remand is to be exercised sparingly and with circumspection, and not in a manner that departs from any express procedure prescribed under the Code, consistent with the limitations laid down by this Court on the exercise of inherent and implied powers to do justice.

d) Remand also serves a corrective function. Where the Adjudicating Authority, on encountering a curable defect in a resolution plan placed before it for approval under Section 31, proceeds to modify the plan in exercise of its own discretion instead of remitting it to the CoC, the NCLAT may remand the plan so as to restore the allocation of roles between the Adjudicating Authority and the CoC.

e) Since a speedy and time-bound resolution is itself an objective of the Code, any order of remand must be accompanied by a strict direction to adhere to the timelines prescribed under the Code and the relevant regulations, so that the remedy does not itself become a source of the very delay that the Code seeks to avoid.

The guidelines arose from Twinstar's challenge to an NCLAT order dated January 5, 2022, which had set aside approval of its resolution plan and sent the matter back to the CoC.

Twinstar's plan, submitted in November 2020, proposed a financial outlay of ₹2,962.02 crore. The CoC approved it with a 95.09% voting share. The NCLT subsequently approved the plan but directed that dissenting financial creditors be paid their liquidation value in cash upfront, before any payment to creditors who had approved the plan.

Three dissenting creditors, Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI Limited, and SIDBI, challenged the approval before the NCLAT. The appellate tribunal found that the plan's provision for payment to dissenting creditors through non-convertible debentures redeemable over six years did not meet the statutory payment requirement. It also held that the NCLT had impermissibly modified the plan by changing the payment arrangement.

The Supreme Court upheld the NCLAT's decision. It observed that the NCLT could not alter the CoC-approved payment structure, as commercial decisions on the plan belonged to the CoC.

Explaining the purpose of remand, the Court said it allows the appellate tribunal to examine the legality of a resolution plan without taking over the CoC's role in deciding its commercial terms.

“The power of remand, therefore, operates as the connecting link between the three actors: it permits the appellate authority to check the legality without trespassing on the commerciality, which is the sole domain of the CoC,” the Court ruled

The top court accordingly dismissed Twinstar's appeals and upheld the NCLAT's decision to set aside approval of the resolution plan and remit the matter to the CoC.

For the Appellants: Advocates: Diwakar Maheshwari, Shreyas Edupuganti, Pratiksha Mishra, Shubham Saini, Bhavika Deora, Gaurav Singh, Sandeep S. Ladda, Advocates on Record Karun Mehta, Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary, Prabhleen Apoorv Shukla, Soumik Ghosal

For the Respondents: Senior Advocate: K. K. Venugopal, Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General of India, N. Venkatraman, Additional Solicitor General of India, Advocates Abhishek Singh, Anoop Rawat, Vaijayant Paliwal, Vishrut Kansal, Moulshree Shukla, Gayathri Balasubramanian, Madhav Kanoria, Surabhi Khattar, Srideepa Bhattacharyya, Neha Shivhare, Shivansh Vishwakarma, Pallavi Agrawal, Vikash Kumar Jha, Sumant Nayak, Rohit Jain, Shraddha Chaudhari, Smriti Shukla, Ankita Sharma, Abhishek Dwivedi, Shaila Arora, Divyansha, Zeeshan Haider, Chinmayee Chandra, Rohini Srinivasan, Ashutosh Chaturvedi, Anindita Roychowdhury, Vatsala Rai, Piyush Bhardwaj, Shivam Sengupta, Tanuj Sud, Ajay Kumar, Stuti Vatsa, Vijayant Goel, Krishan Singhal, Varuna Bhanrale, Ananya Sinha, Shahid Khan, Umesh Dubey, Amrendra Kumar Singh, Amulya Dev Mishra, Shriji Mishra, Shashank Tiwari, Sarthak Tiwari, Piyush Joshi, Sumiti Yadava, Vatsla Bhatia, Aarshia Biju Shantharam, Advocates on Record Badri Prasad Singh, S. S. Shroff, Aslam Ahmed Jamal, Abhijnan Jha, Abhinav Agrawal, Abhikalp Pratap Singh, T. Sundar Ramanathan, Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, Manoj K. Mishra, Sonakshi Malhan, Trilegal, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Shubhanshu Gupta, K. R. Sasiprabhu, Soumik Ghosal.

Tags:    
Case Title :  TWINSTAR TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED VERSUS BANK OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS.Case Number :  CIVIL APPEAL NO. 894 OF 2022CITATION :  2026 LLBiz SC 351