The Gujarat High Court on 3 November held that an employee on deputation to the borrowing department has no fundamental or enforceable right to seek permanent absorption or demand a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the parent department.

Justice Devan M. Desai dismissed a petition filed by Harit Vimalbhai Buch, who was working at the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Ahmedabad, on deputation from the District Court, Junagadh. The Bench held:

“The borrowing department's concern regarding a shortage of staff does not, by itself, confer any legal right upon the petitioner to seek permanent absorption in the establishment of the Debt Recovery Tribunal, Ahmedabad.”

Buch joined the DRT in August 2022. Subsequently, the Tribunal extended his deputation till April 2026, following which he submitted a proposal for permanent absorption.

The DRT forwarded his proposal to the High Court, seeking an NOC from his parent department. However, the department declined to issue the NOC, relying on the Absorption Policy of DRTs and DRATs.

The Court observed that an employee does not have an enforceable right to obtain an NOC for permanent absorption as a matter of course and that an employee appointed on deputation does not possess any fundamental or indefeasible right to be permanently absorbed in the borrowing department.

It added that absorption is not a unilateral process and requires the consent of the employee, the borrowing department and the lending department.

Further, the Bench clarified that refusal to issue an NOC could be challenged if the decision was arbitrary, unreasonable, discriminatory, motivated by personal bias or malice, or contrary to a statutory provision. However, the petitioner failed to establish any such ground.

Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the petition, holding that the petitioner had failed to establish any right warranting judicial intervention.

For Petitioner: Advocate Hriday Buch, along with Advocate Meet A. Shah,

For Respondent No.2: Advocate Ankit Shah appeared

For Respondent No. 1 and 3: Advocate Chintan N. Desai

Tags:    
Case Title :  Harit Vimalbhai Buch v. The District and Sessions Court, Junagadh & Ors.Case Number :  R/Special Civil Application No. 6180 of 2026CITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (GUJ) 171