The Delhi High Court has set aside a ₹10 lakh penalty imposed on a Customs House Agent (CHA) in connection with the alleged illegal import of Chinese firecrackers, observing that the penalty could not be sustained solely on the statements of co-noticees without independent evidence establishing his involvement.
The division bench of Justices Avneesh Jhingan and Shail Jain noted that the penalties imposed on other persons allegedly involved in the transaction had already been quashed and that there was no independent evidence against the appellant.
"In absence of independent evidence against the appellant the different treatment of the appellant from co-noticees cannot be sustained," the Court observed.
The case arose from the seizure of Chinese-made firecrackers allegedly concealed behind bicycle parts and pumps in two containers examined by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) at the Inland Container Depot, Tughlakabad, in 2016.
The Customs Department alleged that the appellant, Harish Goyal, who operated a clearing and forwarding agency in Ludhiana, knew about the misdeclaration of goods and had facilitated the import by arranging meetings with Delhi-based customs agents and enabling the misuse of another firm's KYC documents.
A penalty of ₹10 lakh was imposed on him under Section 112(b)(i) of the Customs Act, which was subsequently upheld by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT).
Challenging the penalty, Goyal argued that he had neither filed the Bill of Entry nor handled the clearance of the consignment. He also contended that the penalty was based on third-party statements and that his request to cross-examine the persons concerned had been rejected.
The High Court noted that the adjudicating authority itself had found that Goyal's role in importing the consignment was not proved. Nevertheless, the penalty was imposed on the ground that he had knowledge of the misdeclaration and had arranged meetings between the persons allegedly involved.
The Court observed that the penalty imposed on Rahul Sehgal, whom the Department had identified as the actual importer, had already been quashed by CESTAT, thereby weakening the foundation of the allegations against Goyal. The penalty against another co-noticee, Saurabh Aggarwal, had also been set aside for lack of independent evidence.
Further, the Court found that Goyal's request to cross-examine three persons whose statements were relied upon against him had been rejected merely to avoid delay. It also noted that CESTAT had incorrectly proceeded on the assumption that no such request had been made.
"There cannot be quarrel with the proposition that the cross-examination is not an absolute right yet falls withing the ambit of principle of natural justice and is in consonance with Section 138(B) of the Act," the Court observed.
As such, the Court allowed the appeal.
For Appellant: Advocates Pradeep Jain & Pritty Jain
For Respondent: Advocates Anurag Ojha, SSC with Dipak Raj, Aryaman Singh Choudhan & Aditya Chaudhary