Test Reports From Live Consignments Cannot Establish Duty Liability On Past Imports: CESTAT Ahmedabad
The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Ahmedabad has set aside customs duty demands, interest and confiscation relating to past consignments of imported fabric, holding that test reports from live consignments cannot be used to establish the composition and classification of earlier imports.
The tribunal observed, “Therefore, in absence of any test report in respect of past consignments and non-fulfilment of this mandatory requirement under Section 138B of the Act, statements tendered by various persons, some of which are also in appeal before us, cannot be taken as credible evidence to fasten the duty liability on the appellants.”
A bench of Judicial Member Somesh Arora and Technical Member Satendra Vikram Singh held that the Department could not extend its findings on live consignments to past imports without consignment-specific test reports or other credible evidence.
The appeals arose from customs investigations into imports by JMV Enterprise, Om Enterprises and other entities. The importers had declared the goods under tariff headings 59119990 and 59050090.
Following intelligence inputs, the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) examined live consignments and sent samples to the Central Revenues Control Laboratory (CRCL), Vadodara. The reports described different varieties of fabric as coated with compounded polyurethane.
The Department alleged that the goods were misdeclared and classifiable under CTH 59032090, attracting anti-dumping duty under Notification No. 14/2022-Customs (ADD) dated May 20, 2022. Relying on test reports and statements recorded during investigation, the adjudicating authorities extended the classification findings to earlier imports and confirmed differential duty demands.
The importers challenged this approach, arguing that test reports relating to one consignment could not establish the composition of goods imported under separate Bills of Entry. They also questioned the reliance on statements without compliance with Section 138B of the Customs Act, 1962.
The tribunal agreed, noting that the adjudicating authority had not examined the admissibility of these statements under Section 138B. It also found no independent evidence linking goods recovered from buyers to the specific past consignments imported by the appellants.
However, the tribunal rejected the argument that fabrics coated with compounded polyurethane fell outside the anti-dumping notification. It observed that adding acrylics, pigments, fillers, plasticisers and other ingredients did not change the essential characteristics of polyurethane. The importers had failed to produce technical literature establishing otherwise.
It also rejected the argument that goods manufactured using the dry process were excluded from the notification, noting that the Designated Authority had expressly considered and rejected such an exclusion.
The tribunal upheld the classification of live consignments, the consequential anti-dumping duty, reassessment and confiscation under Section 111(m) of the Customs Act, along with redemption fines. It set aside the duty demands, interest and confiscation relating to past consignments.
It also directed a proportionate reduction of penalties imposed on the appellants and removed penalties under Section 114A against Jai Maa Enterprises and Skytex.
The appeals were partly allowed.
For Appellant: Manish Jain
For Respondent: Girish Nair