The Customs, Excise, and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Mumbai, has held that an importer cannot be expected to anticipate how Customs authorities may classify imported goods during reassessment or subsequent adjudication proceedings.
It ruled that a difference over tariff classification, by itself, cannot make goods liable to confiscation when they match the description in the Bill of Entry.
A bench of Judicial Member Dr. Suvendu Kumar Pati and Technical Member P.V. Subba Rao observed:
“The importer has to correctly declare the facts in the Bills of Entry but has no obligation under the Customs Act to anticipate the view which the proper officer may take during re-assessment or the adjudicating officer may take in its orders and to file Bills of Entry conforming to such anticipated views. It is also impossible for the importer to so anticipate.”
The tribunal set aside the confiscation of goods imported by Maneesh Pharmaceuticals Ltd., the redemption fines imposed on the company and penalties imposed on its director Maneesh Sapte and customs broker Sunshine Enterprises.
The dispute arose after the company imported capsules of dry mix powder of soy/tofu and flaxseed, classifying them under tariff items 12119011, 12089000 and 12119099. Customs later proposed classifying the goods under CTI 21069099 and demanded differential duty, besides proposing confiscation and penalties.
The tribunal upheld the classification under CTI 21069099, following its earlier decision concerning the same goods imported by the company. It also upheld the differential duty on merits, but held that the classification dispute did not justify confiscation or the penalties.
Under Sections 46 and 17 of the Customs Act, an importer must file a Bill of Entry and self-assess the duty payable. The Bill of Entry contains factual details about the goods as well as the importer's assessment of their classification. The proper officer can verify the declaration under Section 17(2) and reassess the duty under Section 17(4) if the self-assessment is found incorrect.
The tribunal held that Section 111(m), which provides for confiscation when imported goods do not correspond with the particulars in the entry, could not be invoked merely because the authorities later adopted a different classification. In this case, the goods matched their description in the Bills of Entry. Only their classification differed.
Since the goods were not liable to confiscation, the tribunal also set aside the redemption fines imposed under Section 125. It further set aside the penalties imposed on the director and customs broker under Section 112(a), which applies to acts or omissions that render goods liable to confiscation.
The penalty imposed on the importer under Section 114A was also set aside. The tribunal found no evidence of collusion, wilful misstatement, or suppression of facts to establish that the short payment of duty resulted from any of these circumstances. It consequently rejected the extended period of limitation invoked under Section 28(4).
The tribunal partly allowed the company's appeals, upholding duty demands with interest only for the normal limitation period. It set aside the extended-period demands, redemption fines, and Section 114A penalties. The director's and customs broker's appeals were allowed, and the penalties imposed on them were set aside.
For Appellant: Anil Balani and Pasi Deepak Kumar
For Respondent: Bipin Jadhav