The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Chandigarh, has ruled in favour of Parle Biscuits Pvt. Ltd. in a dispute over central excise duty on sugar syrup manufactured inside its factory and used in making biscuits.

The tribunal held that the Department had failed to establish that the syrup was marketable or that it met the fructose-content requirement for classification as a sugar syrup blend containing at least 50% fructose by weight in the dry state.

The bench of Judicial Member Somesh Arora and Technical Member P. Anjani Kumar also held that the syrup qualified for exemption from excise duty under Notification No. 67/95-CE, as Parle had either not availed of CENVAT credit or had reversed the credit, if any, in accordance with the applicable rules.

Parle manufactures the syrup inside its factory by mixing sugar, water and a small quantity of citric acid, and heating the mixture. The syrup is then used in a semi-hot condition to manufacture biscuits.

The dispute arose after biscuits with a retail sale price not exceeding ₹100 per kg became exempt from excise duty in 2007. The Department took the position that the exemption available for intermediate products used in manufacturing dutiable goods was no longer available to the syrup once the biscuits became exempt.

It issued show-cause notices demanding duty on the syrup. The Department also argued that similar sugar syrups were available in the market and that Parle's product could be classified as a sugar syrup blend containing at least 50% fructose by weight in the dry state.

Rejecting the Department's marketability argument, the tribunal noted that the Revenue had relied on products sold by other manufacturers without establishing that their chemical composition was comparable to Parle's syrup.

“In the absence of such a comparative analysis, the marketability of the specific intermediate product in question cannot be presumed or held to be established,” the tribunal observed.

The tribunal also rejected the Department's classification argument. A test conducted by the Central Revenue Control Laboratory (CRCL) had found that the syrup contained 79.9% invert sugar. However, the laboratory had not determined the exact percentage of fructose.

Relying on technical literature that invert sugar consists of equal proportions of glucose and fructose, the tribunal reasoned that the fructose component in Parle's syrup could not exceed approximately 40% by weight.

It therefore held that the Department had failed to establish that the syrup met the minimum fructose-content requirement for the classification it proposed.

The tribunal further noted that the Department had not disputed Parle's submission that it had either not availed of CENVAT credit on the inputs used to manufacture the syrup or had duly reversed the credit, if any, under Rule 6 of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004.

It consequently held that the intermediate syrup was eligible for exemption under Notification No. 67/95-CE.

The tribunal also rejected the argument that Parle's earlier payment of duty on the syrup prevented it from claiming the exemption later. It observed that there is no estoppel against a statute in taxation matters and that a taxpayer is entitled to discontinue an earlier practice that was legally incorrect.

Setting aside the impugned orders, the tribunal allowed the appeals with consequential relief, if any, in accordance with law.

For Appellants: Jatin Mahajan

For Respondent: Goverdhan Dass Bansal, Authorised Representative

Tags:    
Case Title :  Parle Biscuits Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Goods & Service Tax, RohtakCase Number :  Excise Appeal Nos. 1495 and 1496 of 2012CITATION :  2026 LLBiz CESTAT(CHA) 659