CESTAT Delhi Cuts Customs Broker's G-Card Holder's Penalty To ₹5,000 Citing Meagre Salary, Wife's Dialysis
The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, has reduced the ₹1 lakh penalty imposed on a Customs Broker's G-Card holder to ₹5,000 for failing to verify the KYC documents of an importer, Giga Export Services, against the originals before filing six Bills of Entr.
The tribunal took into account his monthly salary of ₹18,000 and his wife's medical condition, which required dialysis.
The Bench of Judicial Member Ajay Sharma and Technical Member Hemambika R. Priya upheld the penalty imposed on Sushil Gautam under Section 112(a)(i) of the Customs Act, 1962, finding that he had violated Regulation 10(n) of the Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018.
The tribunal observed:
“However, we also take note that the appellant was merely the G-card holder, earning a salary of Rs. 18,000/- per month. It has also been submitted that his wife was unwell and was on dialysis. This is corroborated by the F-card holder Shri. Ratan Singh in his statement dated 29.03.2022. We find that the order has imposed Rs. 1,00,000/- under Section 112(a) (i) which we are of the opinion is on the higher side for a person on meager salary of Rs. 18,000/- per month.”
Gautam was employed as a salaried G-Card holder with Ambe Freight Pvt. Ltd. The case arose after Mahesh Ramji Bhanushali approached him at ICD Tughlakabad and requested him to process customs documents for certain consignments.
The Department alleged that Gautam had filed six Bills of Entry for Giga Export Services using forged or morphed KYC documents without informing the firm's F-Card holder, Ratan Singh Bisht. An investigation found that the firm did not exist at its declared address and that the PAN and Aadhaar documents submitted for KYC did not match the originals.
Gautam argued that there was no evidence of his conscious involvement or prior knowledge of the alleged misdeclaration. He also relied on an earlier tribunal decision setting aside the revocation of the Customs Broker's licence, arguing that the penalty against him could not stand.
Rejecting this argument, the tribunal examined Gautam's individual conduct. It noted that he knew about a Customs alert but did not inform the F-Card holder. He had also filed the documents using his own ID and an independent digital signature dongle.
The tribunal clarified that a Customs Broker is not required to physically verify the importer's address. However, Gautam had admitted in his statement dated May 9, 2022, that he had not verified the KYC documents against the originals. This violated Regulation 10(n) of the CBLR, 2018, making him liable for a penalty.
Considering his financial circumstances, the tribunal reduced the penalty to ₹5,000 and modified the impugned order to that extent.
For Appellant: N. K. Sharma and Kapil Gautam
For Respondent: N. M. Goel, Authorised Representative