The Karnataka High Court has upheld an arbitral award rejecting Pragati Metallurgical Services' Rs. 98.80 lakh claim against Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) for reimbursement of increased minimum wages paid to workers under a steel finishing contract.

A Division Bench comprising Justices D.K. Singh and H. Shanthi Bhushan held that a contractor's statutory obligation to pay revised minimum wages does not, by itself, create a contractual obligation on the employer to reimburse the additional expenditure. The judges observed:

“The Commercial Court has rightly noticed that the statutory obligation of the petitioner to pay revised wages cannot, by itself, be converted into a contractual obligation on the part of the respondent to reimburse the same. We do not find any perversity in the said reasoning.”

SAIL accepted Pragati Metallurgical Services' bid on April 25, 2016, and issued a work order worth Rs. 8.95 crore the following day for steel finishing work at its Visvesvaraya Iron and Steel Plant in Bhadravathi.

The contract, which ran from May 1, 2016, to April 30, 2019, covered finishing rolled materials and straightening and cutting forged steel products.

Under the contract, the contractor had to pay minimum wages, including dearness allowance, at the rates notified by the appropriate government from time to time. The government revised minimum wages in January and April 2017. The contractor claimed that the January revision increased wages by nearly 40%.

On September 26, 2017, SAIL clarified that Central Government wage notifications applied to the plant and that the contractor could not claim reimbursement for increases arising from subsequent notifications.

Through a legal notice dated March 2, 2018, the contractor demanded Rs. 26.70 lakh and the wage difference for the remaining contract period. SAIL's reply dated March 30, 2018, referred the contractor to the conciliation and arbitration clause in the agreement.

Subsequently, the contractor claimed Rs. 72,10,119 towards additional wage costs and Rs. 26,70,280 as interest, along with further interest at 18% per annum. The sole arbitrator dismissed the claim with costs on September 16, 2021.

On January 30, 2025, the Commercial Court at Bhadravathi declined to set aside the arbitral award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Pragati Metallurgical Services then challenged the decision before the High Court under Section 37 of the Act.

The contractor argued that the arbitrator had overlooked the extent of the wage increase. It also contended that SAIL's reimbursement of additional statutory bonus demonstrated that it had accepted liability for increased statutory costs.

SAIL maintained that the contractor had agreed to pay wages at revised rates under the contract. It further argued that reimbursement of statutory bonus arose from a specific arrangement and could not establish a general obligation to reimburse wage increases.

The High Court found that the contract already contemplated revisions in minimum wages by requiring the contractor to comply with government notifications issued from time to time.

It held that SAIL's reimbursement of statutory bonus did not create a separate contractual obligation to reimburse increased wages. It also found that SAIL's reply referring the contractor to the dispute resolution clause did not amount to an acknowledgment of liability.

Further, the Bench observed that even if the contractor had paid the entire amount claimed to its workers, its entitlement to recover that amount from SAIL depended on the terms of the contract.

It found that the arbitrator had adopted a permissible interpretation of the agreement and that the Commercial Court had not exceeded the limited scope of review under Section 34 of the Act.

Accordingly, the High Court affirmed the Commercial Court's judgment and dismissed the appeal without an order as to costs.

Appearances for appellant (Pragati Metallurgical Services): Advocate Venkatesh P. Dalwai.

Tags:    
Case Title :  Pragati Metallurgical Services Forging Inspection & Consultant v. The Steel Authority of India Ltd. & Anr.Case Number :  Commercial Appeal No. 202 of 2025 | 2026:KHC:54134-DBCITATION :  2026 LLBiz HC (KAR) 242