The Principal Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), New Delhi, on 19 November held that a statutory auditor can be proceeded against under Section 339 of the Companies Act, 2013, for knowingly participating in fraudulent conduct of a company's business, even if he was not part of its management.
A Bench comprising President Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal and Technical Member Ravindra Chaturvedi dismissed an application filed by the widow of a statutory auditor of Bhushan Power and Steel Limited (BPSL), seeking deletion of her deceased husband's name from proceedings initiated by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO). It observed:
“...the existence of separate provisions under which an auditor may be proceeded against for lapses in his professional duties does not take him out of Section 339, because Section 339(4) expressly provides that the Section applies even where the person is punishable under any other law. The relief claimed against the deceased herein is under Section 339 of the Act and not under Section 242 of the Act.”
The widow contended that the criminal proceedings against her husband had abated upon his death and, therefore, the claim could not survive against his estate.
Rejecting the contention, the Tribunal observed that Section 339 creates a right of action which survives against the estate of the deceased. It held that the legal heirs could remain on record in a representative capacity to defend the action against the estate, if any.
It held that an auditor who certifies false accounts or conceals information about fraud, thereby facilitating the company to carry on fraudulent business, would fall within the scope of Section 339(1).
Further, it clarified that the word “knowingly” under Section 339(1) requires knowledge and participation, and the burden of proving such participation lies on the SFIO. It observed:
“...the word “knowingly” in Section 339(1) of the Act requires knowledge and participation, and the burden of proving knowing participation lies on the SFIO. Whether the deceased was merely careless or was knowingly a party to the fraud is a disputed question of fact which can be decided only at the final hearing and not in an application for deletion of a party”
Moreover, the Bench clarified that the SFIO must substantiate, through cogent material, that the deceased auditor knew of the alleged fraud and participated in it.
Accordingly, the NCLT directed the SFIO to file a consolidated statement specifying the allegations, relevant financial years, documents relied upon and the amount sought to be recovered from the estate. It also restrained the SFIO from taking any action against the widow until the final decision.
For the Union of India through SFIO/ Petitioner: Mr. Aditya Sikka, Adv. a/w Ms. Onshi Jakhar, Ms. Yuganshi Singh, Advs.
For the Applicants in C.A. 222 of 2023/ Respondent No. 75: Mr. Nesar Ahmad, PCS a/w Mr. Ahsan Ahmad, Mr. Rachit Ranjan, Mr. Manish Kumar, Mr. Aayush Kumar, Advs.