The Hyderabad Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), on 18 November allowed the impleadment application filed by Talluru Ravi Prasad, the proposed purchaser of land belonging to Winsol Green Power Private Limited, in the oppression and mismanagement petition filed by Bandikatla Murthy Mohana against the company.

A Bench of Judicial Member Rajeev Bhardwaj and Technical Member Sanjay Puri held that a non-shareholder or non-director can be impleaded in proceedings under Sections 241 and 242 of the Companies Act, 2013, if the person demonstrates a direct interest in the subject matter and their presence would aid effective adjudication. It said:

“Ordinarily, reliefs in such proceedings are sought against the Company and persons alleged to be responsible for acts of oppression and mismanagement. However, the absence of membership or directorship, by itself, does not preclude the impleadment of a non-member who demonstrates a direct interest in the subject matter of the proceedings and whose presence would facilitate the complete and effective adjudication of the questions involved.”

The dispute concerned the validity of the company's Board Meeting and Extra-Ordinary General Meeting held in January 2019 and the resolutions passed therein. Ravi Prasad entered into an Agreement of Sale with Winsol Green Power Private Limited in February 2019 to purchase 47.19 guntas of land for Rs. 4,74,75,000. He claimed to have paid an advance of Rs. 1,50,00,000 and executed a Deed of Extension in September 2020.

Mohana filed a petition under Section 241 of the Companies Act, alleging oppression and mismanagement. He sought a declaration that the Board Meeting and Extra-Ordinary General Meeting held in January 2019 were illegal and that the resolutions passed therein were not binding on the company or its shareholders.

In May 2022, the Tribunal restrained the company from alienating any of its assets pending further orders in the company petition.

Ravi Prasad sought impleadment, contending that the disputed resolutions were connected to the authority under which the sale agreement was executed and that the interim order affected his contractual interest in the land. He claimed to be a bona fide purchaser and a proper and necessary party to the proceedings.

The Tribunal referred to the Supreme Court's ruling in Moreshar Yadaorao Mahajan v. Vyankatesh Sitaram Bhedi, Civil Appeal Nos. 5755 and 5756 of 2011, which explained the distinction between a necessary party and a proper party. It said:

“A proper party, on the other hand, is one whose presence enables the Court to completely, effectively and adequately adjudicate upon the questions involved, even though no relief may be claimed against such a person.”

Further, the Bench observed that the controversy concerning the validity of the meetings and the authority to deal with the company's assets directly affected Ravi Prasad's contractual interest. His claim arose from a transaction connected with the resolutions under challenge and was not remote or unrelated to the proceedings. It said:

“Though the Applicant is neither a member nor a Director of the Company, and no independent relief is claimed against him, his presence would assist this Tribunal in adjudicating the controversy involved in the Company Petition...”

Accordingly, the NCLT held that Ravi Prasad was a proper party, though not a necessary party, and allowed his impleadment application.

For Applicant: Nishita B. and Srilekha

For Respondent Nos. 1 and 2: Y. Suryanarayana

Respondent Nos. 5 and 13: Sridhar and K.V. Raman

Tags:    
Case Title :  Talluru Ravi Prasad v. Bandikatla Murthy Mohana & Ors.Case Number :  IA (CA) No. 195/2025 in CP (CA) No. 22/241/HDB/2022; Intervention Petition (CA) No. 01/2025CITATION :  2026 LLBiz NCLT (HYD) 1151